The Most Valuable Player of The NFL...

[shag773]

I think if Vick continues to play as he's had in the 4 games he started and stay healthy, he is certainly in the discussion. But at this point of the season it's a little early. W2TD is right on point with Rivers. Although I do think the Chargers make the playoffs, especially with their receivers getting healthy and Vincent Jackson back by week 12.

 

[ram29jackson]

...is Michael Vick?

Yeah... that guy. I mean, I can't name another player in the NFL that has been as on-point as this guy. Sure, his stats will be diminished because of injury, but when he's playing, I haven't seen anyone else in the league play at the level this guy has and I think last night solidified it:

Mike Vick is on another fucking planet.

I mean, he'll eventually have a bad game (my friends who are Eagles fans think that he may goof against my Giants, but even I'm skeptic of that), but I just don't see anyone else that stands out like Vick does.

62.7%, 1350 yards, 11 TD, 0 INT - 341 RUSH yards, 4 RUSH TD

And he's undefeated as a starter this season (4-0). I mean, this just may be a case of Vick just being on a hotstreak, but no one has been on his level in my opinion. I'm not even looking at this from a stat standpoint. He's playing like he's the best player in the NFL right now. I don't know how the MVP race looks to anyone else, but who else is up here with this guy?

aww shut up. You just saw an athletic QB have a really good night. It wont matter come playoff time.

 

[ram29jackson]

Vick is certainly in the discussion, but he's started less than half of his team's games, and it's not like the team was a disaster under Kolb.

As Archer pointed out, Rivers is playing with bums and is the QB of the #1 offense in the NFL. However, the Chargers have to make the playoffs before I can take him seriously as MVP. He sorta reminds me of Drew Brees two years ago, when people were touting him for MVP even though the Saints were in last place. Actually, Kyle Orton reminds me a lot of 2008 Brees.

The "boring" choices are Manning and Brady, but both are valid contenders.

As far as non QB's, I don't see much out there. No RB is having a MVP caliber season. WR's have to be speciall, and there is nobody doing anything special. Matthews isnt quite dominant enough for an MVP.

thats some number one offense.....? Chargers 4-5

 

[mgoblue2290]

If Vick keeps it up for the rest of the season, which I doubt will happen, then it'd be a tough call between him and Rivers for MVP.

 

[Juggernaut]

aww shut up. You just saw an athletic QB have a really good night. It wont matter come playoff time.

Pretty sure the resident Packers fans could tell you otherwise.

 

[ram29jackson]

Pretty sure the resident Packers fans could tell you otherwise.

career wins in wild card rounds dont mean crap.

the Eagles stopped Vick from making it to the Super Bowl the first time

and the Eagles will stop Vick again. On a more first hand level this time.

 

[Tengo Juego]

Let's talk about this in about 5 weeks. When it makes sense to.

 

[Derrville]

Hes only played 4 and a half games. Were in week 11 now theres no way hes even in the MVP discussion. And like others said, 3 of his 4 wins are against Washington, Jacksonville, and Detroit. Too early to start talking about his MVP chances.

 

[Maize]

Tom Brady, Vick didn't play all 16 games and Brady is doing it without the supporting cast Manning or Vick are working with.

 

[Rush]

Can't wait until he plays the Bears. He has never trumped us before and just made us look foolish, hoping that won't start this season.

 

[ram29jackson]

if he's lucky, he might get comeback player of the year

 

[Colonel Angus]

Vick won't win MVP with all the games he's missed. Plus that team won a couple games pretty easily with Kolb out there. Rivers will probably win it barring a great second half from Peyton or CMIII putting up 20+ sacks.

 

[Archer]

Tom Brady, Vick didn't play all 16 games and Brady is doing it without the supporting cast Manning or Vick are working with.

What? Is this like an auto-defense for Brady fans or something?

The Colts offense has 4 starters missing and 2 undrafted free agents seeing meaningful playing time.

Not to mention a patched up o-line

EDIT: For the record, Manning wouldn't be my MVP right now. As I said earlier... Rivers would be.

 

[citizenerased]

Tom Brady, Vick didn't play all 16 games and Brady is doing it without the supporting cast Manning or Vick are working with.

Yeah, where would Manning be without that supporting cast of Joseph Tamme, Brandon James and Javarris James (Bet you just googled all three of those names).

In other words - Bitch, stay off that blow.

 

[Deviant]

If a kicker can win NFL MVP, I don't see how Michael Vick, who's only not played in 3 games this season, can't win the MVP. Sure, we have a small sampling for Vick, but if he stays healthy and continues at this level, I don't see how he can't be.

 

[Deviant]

aww shut up. You just saw an athletic QB have a really good night. It wont matter come playoff time.

You are the worst poster ever.

 

[inthecards21]

Philip Rivers will break records with a terrible group of receivers, also when you have arguably the best backup quarterback in the league, you can't really be considered more valuable than manning, brady or rivers

 

[celtsxpatsxsox]

Vick needs to play in more than 4 games (full games) before I put him in the MVP discussion. Right now its between Brady, Manning and Rivers. If the Chargers make the playoffs then Rivers runs away with it imo. (if he keeps playing the same way)

 

[Raidersabc123]

Rivers wont win it cause his team wont even make the playoffs

 

[x0xHumblex0x]

Mike Vick....MVP?
really?? and this is based on 1 MNF game?? i am not saying he cant play cause he definitely can play in "Todays League".
he defintely gets "comback kid" in my book but lets face it.
QBs this year suck ass. they are all having a mediocre year compared to the years past.

JMHO