Two Months Later: Your Thoughts On The Game?

[St. Francisco]

So, a little more than two months since the release of the game, I wanted to see how you guys feel about the game at this point. How are your dynasties going, are the game flaws too much to handle, etc?

I'm actually looking at starting up a dynasty...how are you guys doing in terms of realism? Simmed stats, progression, are things ridiculous?

 

[St. Francisco]

Haven't started a dynasty up yet because of progression. I have fun playing with my sliders, but I just can't fall in love with this game. I'm looking to start a dynasty in the next week or so though

Speaking of which, has anyone heard anything on a patch for progression?

 

[LC AAU]

I still love this game. I run an Online Dynasty here, and I'm in the 2 other 360 ones here.

Plus I have my Purdue Dynasty on here, and I'm still loving it.

Only problem is the progression, but oh well. I'll live.

 

[Coked Up Elmo]

love it, have like 6 or so dynasties with 3 years or more, always finding some other team that is fun to start a new dynasty with, most recently is iowa state using nevada's playbook

 

[Proof21]

Still really enjoy this game...in fact I have several updates I need to get posted with my Nebraska dynasty.

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

Its an ok game, its just boring. The lack of presentation really kills a lot of the fun aspect of it.

It is a college football game, I should feel more of what its like to play college football.

 

[1ke]

Im on 2 ODs. And cant get enough of those. After all the hype surrounding Madden and then playing that. Ive come back to this, i enjoy this game way more. I dont even really want to play madden again, ever.

 

[NateDogg7240]

I still like the game a lot. The only problem is that I haven't had a lot of time to play it with college starting and I just started my Madden franchise.

 

[JTRaines92]

The game sucks, the games are predetermined, the computer has advantages on Heisman, the game is terrible and I want my money back!

 

[Realist]

just starting season 2 in a OD im running. im enjoying the game. some games a frustrating but for the most part im enjoying. ive played some realistic games vs the computer and thats some that i really like. progression is crazy tho. guess get better way too fast

 

[kyhadley]

The only thing keeping me playing it has been my dynasty. (Click my sig!)

/shameless plug

 

[Maynard]

i love this thread is an excuse for the same group of people who complained and stopped playing weeks after its release to come back an complain some more.

this thread is about people who still play the game.

i still would be playing if not for the dirty disc error i get everytime i put it in. I traded it in, but didnt get another copy because i am enjoying madden

 

[JrRawlins]

i love it.....

 

[1ke]

i love this thread is an excuse for the same group of people who complained and stopped playing weeks after its release to come back an complain some more.

this thread is about people who still play the game.

i still would be playing if not for the dirty disc error i get everytime i put it in. I traded it in, but didnt get another copy because i am enjoying madden

Maynard...Dirty Disc Error is more a Xbox problem than a disc problem. It was for me at least.

 

[Derrville]

Enjoy this more than Madden at times.

 

[dlorton0844]

I think we all (those who hate it and those who are still playing it) can agree that there is definitely more they could do with the presentation aspect. How about a short college gameday video each week with predictions?

I also agree that sometimes games seem predetermined. But overall, I still really enjoy playing the online dynasty.

Also, I'm surprised at how much I've gotten into the season showdown. While it may seem worthless to some I like how it makes you conscious of the way you play the game.

Some people are just madden fans, and that's cool with me. But don't hate this game cuz it ain't madden

 

[LC AAU]

I agree Dlorton, Season Showdown is addicting, I find myself trying to get all the points I can get lol.

I'm currently 8th on Purdue's list.

 

[Vinsane]

Madden has really killed this game for me, I still plan on getting a dynasty off the ground, but I'm too busy with my Madden Franchise :dontknow:

 

[Boucher]

Lack of presentation killed this game instantly for me

 

[packersfan4eva]

i <3 ncaa