Enough is enough. Peyton Manning is the greatest QB of all time.

[BazookaJoe5]

Eli Manning > Peyton Manning.

[Hasselbeck]

It will be interesting to see how long Manning plays and the numbers he winds up with at the end of his career. Manning is 33 now but aside from last year has been pretty much as healthy as can be. Should he continue this .. I can see him playing another 6-8 years easily.

[Anthony]

Greatest of all-time hands down & I don't even need to explain why I feel that way.

[Tailback U]

Easily one of the best of all time, but I'll let this season play out before calling him the absolute best of all time.

He truly is a pleasure to watch.

[MmmmBeeeeer]

I'll go ahead and get my negative out of the way. I believe with all my heart that if the Florida Gators played the Indianapolis Colts, the Gators would win. I say that because, being as good as he is, I'm bitter because he never beat Florida when he played for UT.

That being said, it is a far shame that everyone refers to Peyton as a QB. He is not a QB nor has he been since I'll say at least high school. If we're gonna talk about him let's call it like it is, he is the greatest participating coach of all times. I for one can't wait til he retires. I forsee him retiring after his next SB victory, but maybe he'll go for 2 in a row then retire.

Once he retires I see him going on to be the highest paid HC in NCAA historyn and having the best Tennessee Volunteers team since the inception of football at that school.

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ytCEuuW2_A"]YouTube - The Price is Right losing horn[/ame]

[Sharkweather]

Dont worry MmmmBeeeeer, that guy is one of the biggest homers on this site.

[DSpydr84]

I'm a big Jim Kelly fan, I think a lot of people would be talking about him if they would've won one of those Superbowls. He was really the originator at calling the entire offense at the line and making sight adjustments.. and no one can really argue how great that Bills offense was for a long period of time. Is he the best ever? I suppose you could make a case for it.

[mgoblue2290]

I'll go ahead and get my negative out of the way. I believe with all my heart that if the Florida Gators played the Indianapolis Colts, the Gators would win. I say that because, being as good as he is, I'm bitter because he never beat Florida when he played for UT.

All of your credibility has just gone out the window. Tebow and the mighty Gators beating an NFL team? Please, Peyton would pick the Gators apart. The Gators couldn't beat any NFL team(insert Raiders/Bills/Browns joke). I'd like to see how effective the Gator offense would be against an NFL defense. The Gators might be lucky enough to get in field goal range a few times.

Anyways, one more Super Bowl and Peyton is the GOAT by far. Even now I'd have a tough time putting Montana ahead of him. Like Warner said, if I had to pick any player to start a franchise with, it'd be Peyton.

[riley420]

I'll go ahead and get my negative out of the way. I believe with all my heart that if the Florida Gators played the Indianapolis Colts, the Gators would win. I say that because, being as good as he is, I'm bitter because he never beat Florida when he played for UT.

That being said, it is a far shame that everyone refers to Peyton as a QB. He is not a QB nor has he been since I'll say at least high school. If we're gonna talk about him let's call it like it is, he is the greatest participating coach of all times. I for one can't wait til he retires. I forsee him retiring after his next SB victory, but maybe he'll go for 2 in a row then retire.

Once he retires I see him going on to be the highest paid HC in NCAA historyn and having the best Tennessee Volunteers team since the inception of football at that school.

All of your credibility has just gone out the window. Tebow and the mighty Gators beating an NFL team? Please, Peyton would pick the Gators apart. The Gators couldn't beat any NFL team(insert Raiders/Bills/Browns joke). I'd like to see how effective the Gator offense would be against an NFL defense. The Gators might be lucky enough to get in field goal range a few times.

Anyways, one more Super Bowl and Peyton is the GOAT by far. Even now I'd have a tough time putting Montana ahead of him. Like Warner said, if I had to pick any player to start a franchise with, it'd be Peyton.

What my esteemed Tennessee fan friend was trying to say there was that Peyton Manning went 0-4 against the Gators in college, and never really came close. It must kill him, too, that they won the NC the year after he left.

Peyton Manning....0 for forever against the Gators.

[inthecards21]

manning
montana
marino

[RainboUnicorn]

I'll go ahead and get my negative out of the way. I believe with all my heart that if the Florida Gators played the Indianapolis Colts, the Gators would win. I say that because, being as good as he is, I'm bitter because he never beat Florida when he played for UT.

That being said, it is a far shame that everyone refers to Peyton as a QB. He is not a QB nor has he been since I'll say at least high school. If we're gonna talk about him let's call it like it is, he is the greatest participating coach of all times. I for one can't wait til he retires. I forsee him retiring after his next SB victory, but maybe he'll go for 2 in a row then retire.

Once he retires I see him going on to be the highest paid HC in NCAA historyn and having the best Tennessee Volunteers team since the inception of football at that school.

lol.

[Fox1994]

I think he's number two as a prototypical QB to Johnny U. I like Randall, too, as he was one of the greatest scramblers of all time, but if you're looking for a classic drop-back, I'd go with John Unitas, and then Peyton.

He's still amazing, though. He's definitely the best who's playing right now. After him I'd take Brady or McNabb.

[young2rice]

I'm a big Jim Kelly fan, I think a lot of people would be talking about him if they would've won one of those Superbowls. He was really the originator at calling the entire offense at the line and making sight adjustments.. and no one can really argue how great that Bills offense was for a long period of time. Is he the best ever? I suppose you could make a case for it.

Thurman Thomas was with him though for his entire career. I think that greatly helped a lot and might take away slightly from Kelly. While Manning has had James (not as good as thomas imo but still good) then Addai (nowhere near as good) and now the brown combo he's got going.

Also Jim Kelly had 175 interceptions in 11 years, Manning has had 169 in 12 years (in 12th) and has 12,000 more yards, 4.6% more accurate, and 108 more touchdowns. Even if Kelly did win one of those rings he'd be equal in the ring stat to Manning, but Manning crushes him in everything else.

[Gonzo]

I think he's number two as a prototypical QB to Johnny U. I like Randall, too, as he was one of the greatest scramblers of all time, but if you're looking for a classic drop-back, I'd go with John Unitas, and then Peyton.

He's still amazing, though. He's definitely the best who's playing right now. After him I'd take Brady or McNabb.

Aren't you like 15? ESPN Classic doesn't show you everything ya'know.

[Sharkweather]

Mgoblue bit hard on that one... I'm shocked.