It is hard not to blame Peyton when you see the ENTIRE O-line all take their first step at the same damn time. They were all perfectly in-sync on what would've most likely been a run play it looked like.
Enough is enough. Peyton Manning is the greatest QB of all time.
Collapse
X
-
-
Originally posted by ram29jacksonI already said months ago that Seattle wasn't winning any SBComment
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
The Following User Says No Thank You to ram29jackson For This un-Useful Post:
MaynardLast edited by ram29jackson; 02-04-2014, 04:26 PM.Comment
-
-
McCarthy gives Rodgers 2.5 seconds to get the ball out. Manning had two ints with his team down 29-0 in the first half or early in the second. Manning contributed to the loss. The entire team caused the loss, but Manning contributed to it. You're sounding as bad as Bill trying to defend Favre. Manning did NOT have a good game.
I didn't think Manning was GOAT before the game. I would have picked two other QB's before him. And the game did nothing to change my mind. I'm OK with someone else believing Manning is GOAT. He has a tremendous resume. But I would pick Unitas and Montana before Manning.Comment
-
There's a difference between calling a play to take 2.5 seconds and calling a play that is supposed to take 4 or 5 seconds and only having 2.5. Manning didn't have open receivers yet constant pressure in his face. The checkdowns were all he had when he had to get rid of the ball.
I was a Manning fan before Peyton even started college. Archie was my second favorite QB behind Bart Starr back in the 60's early 70's. I felt really bad for Archie being on such putrid Saints teams. When his kids started playing QB, I was instant fans of theirs. I'm just not some blind Manning homer. Top 5 QB all time, yes. Top 3 QB all time, very likely. GOAT, I don't believe so. And he did not have a good SB performance on Sunday.Comment
-
So Manning should have audibled to different plays that only take 2.5 seconds. That's what Rodgers has to do. Hell, Rodgers is expected to get rid of the ball in less than 2.5 seconds. That's how they practice. Hell, McCarthy has a horn that blows after 2.5 seconds in practice and the ball had better be out of Rodgers hands. If Manning is running plays that take 4/5 seconds when he knows he has less than 3, that doesn't support your argument. You're sounding like a blind Manning homer.
I was a Manning fan before Peyton even started college. Archie was my second favorite QB behind Bart Starr back in the 60's early 70's. I felt really bad for Archie being on such putrid Saints teams. When his kids started playing QB, I was instant fans of theirs. I'm just not some blind Manning homer. Top 5 QB all time, yes. Top 3 QB all time, very likely. GOAT, I don't believe so. And he did not have a good SB performance on Sunday.Comment
-
So Manning should have audibled to different plays that only take 2.5 seconds. That's what Rodgers has to do. Hell, Rodgers is expected to get rid of the ball in less than 2.5 seconds. That's how they practice. Hell, McCarthy has a horn that blows after 2.5 seconds in practice and the ball had better be out of Rodgers hands. If Manning is running plays that take 4/5 seconds when he knows he has less than 3, that doesn't support your argument. You're sounding like a blind Manning homer.
I was a Manning fan before Peyton even started college. Archie was my second favorite QB behind Bart Starr back in the 60's early 70's. I felt really bad for Archie being on such putrid Saints teams. When his kids started playing QB, I was instant fans of theirs. I'm just not some blind Manning homer. Top 5 QB all time, yes. Top 3 QB all time, very likely. GOAT, I don't believe so. And he did not have a good SB performance on Sunday.Comment
-
Let me go back to what I originally said. I said Manning had a good game, not a great game, not a bad game, just good. He threw for 280 yards while under constant pressure and having had possessions taken away. Drives just weren't finished, touchdowns weren't scored, playcalls were terrible, defense didn't do anything to stop the Seahawks.
Fantasy Football has ruined people's idea of what is a good and bad game. Over 60% of his stats came when Denver was down 29-36 points. Peyton also got away with ANOTHER pick 6 before half on 4th and 2 (Thurmond fell down), and a pass that would have been picked off by Sherman had Demaryius not interfered.
Again.. the Super Bowl loss does not take away from what Peyton did this season or his entire career. He's a Top 3 QB all-time (I personally feel the order is Montana, Manning, Elway) .. but he did NOT play well on Sunday. That's not insulting Peyton.. it's telling the truth.Originally posted by ram29jacksonI already said months ago that Seattle wasn't winning any SBComment
-
Fantasy Football has ruined people's idea of what is a good and bad game. Over 60% of his stats came when Denver was down 29-36 points. Peyton also got away with ANOTHER pick 6 before half on 4th and 2 (Thurmond fell down), and a pass that would have been picked off by Sherman had Demaryius not interfered.
Again.. the Super Bowl loss does not take away from what Peyton did this season or his entire career. He's a Top 3 QB all-time (I personally feel the order is Montana, Manning, Elway) .. but he did NOT play well on Sunday. That's not insulting Peyton.. it's telling the truth.
Elway before Brady ?Comment
-
Fantasy Football has ruined people's idea of what is a good and bad game. Over 60% of his stats came when Denver was down 29-36 points. Peyton also got away with ANOTHER pick 6 before half on 4th and 2 (Thurmond fell down), and a pass that would have been picked off by Sherman had Demaryius not interfered.
Again.. the Super Bowl loss does not take away from what Peyton did this season or his entire career. He's a Top 3 QB all-time (I personally feel the order is Montana, Manning, Elway) .. but he did NOT play well on Sunday. That's not insulting Peyton.. it's telling the truth.Comment
-
Let me go back to what I originally said. I said Manning had a good game, not a great game, not a bad game, just good. He threw for 280 yards while under constant pressure and having had possessions taken away. Drives just weren't finished, touchdowns weren't scored, playcalls were terrible, defense didn't do anything to stop the Seahawks.Comment
Comment