It's the same with Dragon Gate (Japan) too.
I'll watch Infinity, and see two matches that blow me away, or i'll watch a PPV and the entire show will blow my doors off, but because it's all so good and always so consistent, nothing ever stands out. And it doesn't help that nearly everybody is 5'10" and works exactly the same style.
We talk about these recent New Japan shows where nearly the whole card is amazing top to bottom, but Dragon Gate has quietly done this for years. I mean, if I was really being fair, if I ranked the top ten shows every year, Dragon Gate would probably occupy 5-8 spots every time. But it's a brainfuck and actually sort of a deterrent. Sometimes you need Great Khali or Captain New Japan to break things up and let your mind breath.