Cabrera

[Youk]

I misread your post. I didnt realize I was wrong, I minsinterpreted what you said.

Misread, Misinterpret (gotta spell that one right), misremember, they all equal wrong.

 

[Youk]

Why would you want Miggy when he's nothing more than an average player putting up average numbers and can't compete for an MVP?

I like average.

By the way...

Kept it up? Yea, he's got impressive numbers. At this pace? No, I don't think so. Actually, I know so. MVP numbers? No way. Sorry, your little Cabrera hasn't been higher than 5th in the MVP voting. Ever. Expect a typical 30 HR, 120 RBI, .310 BA, but nothing more. You're hailing him as the great savior of the world. Truth.

30 HR, 120 RBI, .310 BA is AVERAGE for him.

 

[spidey12293]

Swisher > Miggy

/thread

 

[Youk]

Swisher > Miggy

/thread

Oh totally....

:jonesy:

 

[Youk]

Why not? We saw his pitching arm last night! lol

Sad when Swisher has a better inning than the majority of Yankee pitchers

 

[Youk]

He pitched a little better than the Tigers staff in 2003.

That's not saying much though.

 

[The Messenger]

Garbage ass Tigers and their fat ass first baseman.

 

[Youk]

Funny that everyone was all over Cabrera's dick until he got traded to a contender, and now everyone thinks he's overrated or not good.

I don't know, he just seems like an average, mediocre player. Obviously.

 

[Youk]

:jonesy:

mediocre?

Sarcasm.

The state of Michigan fails at it.

 

[Youk]

Says the A's fan? Huh?

Yea, the A's with all those young pitchers once again, and a middle of the order that most teams would dream of.

 

[Youk]

Holliday, Giambi, and Nomar! The dream team

Aw, the Tigers fan learned sarcasm.

Cust, Holliday, Giambi. Pretty decent middle of the order power wise. MVPete has it dead on, the A's have a better chance in the West than the Tigers do in the Central.

 

[Youk]

For the world:

Stats for the past three seasons.

Similar players. Miggy is offensively better, and they're closest power-wise. Miggy has the better OBP, SLG, BA, among others.

ok? congratulations?

Hell of an argument.

 

[Youk]

Thanks for proving my point I guess?

Anything to limit the amount of posts of yours that I need to read.

 

[Youk]

Huh? You say Gonzalez is a better player, I say otherwise, then you go prove how I am right so you dont have to read my posts? Are you sure what a debate or argument is?

:jonesy:

I never said Gonzalez was better. That was MVPete. Get ya people right.

 

[spidey12293]

lol
read the post right above you.

 

[mfbmike]

MIGUEL CABRERA = MVP

typing in bigger letters means my point is more valid regardless of what statistical argument you choose to come back with. fuck off.

 

[Youk]

Both players are stars but Miggy has had better hitters in front and back of him the last 3 seasons as well. I fucked up by bringing up Petco because Comerica is just as much a pitchers park. So I take back what I said and say that Miggy is definitely>Adrian at this point in time.

On that note, imagine if both of those guys played in hitters parks, like Citizens Bank. That'd be insane.

 

[Youk]

Buster Olney talking about the Tigers may hit a point that they put Cabrera out there, but only at 10% right now. But as always he says they start losing games, and losing ticket sales, that % increases. That can be said about just about anyone though.

Agreed with the ending. If you look at the reported and unreported waiver wire towards the trading deadline and there are always big time players on it, since the teams can take the player back off waivers. I know Manny, Mike Piazza, and Andruw Jones (when he was great), are examples.

 

[FirstTimer]

Albert Pujols>>Cabrera.

 

[FedEx227]

Ian Kinsler = MVP

Which he or Carlos Quentin would have won if not for injuries.