Could LSU lose to Alabama in the National Championship and still be #1?

[ZoneBlitz]

It wasn't worth stating originally.

Then it damn sure wasnt worth making a poll like you did.

 

[FirstTimer]

A playoff would still be subjective!

The results wouldn't be.

What we basically have now is people playing a subjective playoff out int her mind all season to pick two teams. I'd rather have a subjective 4-8 teams chosen and let the games actually occur then what it is now.

 

[FirstTimer]

Then it damn sure wasnt worth making a poll like you did.

bama:

 

[ZoneBlitz]

The results wouldn't be.

What we basically have now is people playing a subjective playoff out int her mind all season to pick two teams. I'd rather have a subjective 4-8 teams chosen and let the games actually occur then what it is now.

Yeah me too. Zero relevance to this 3 page argument.

 

[FirstTimer]

Yeah me too. Zero relevance to this 3 page argument.

No shit?!

 

[ZoneBlitz]

Many people currently have LSU>Bama even if they lose...if there was a playoff, there is no major reason to change that...unless those people needed a playoff win from Bama to validate them.

 

[FirstTimer]

Many people currently have LSU>Bama even if they lose

Irrelevant.

if there was a playoff, there is no major reason to change that

Yes there would be.

What planet do you live on?

 

[ZoneBlitz]

Yes there would be.

Why??

Each team would each have one extra playoff win...but LSU would still have beaten far more good teams...so why??

:whut:

 

[FirstTimer]

Why??

Because of the way people view playoffs and their results on this planet ALF.

 

[ZoneBlitz]

Because of the way people view playoffs and their results on this planet ALF.

So just because its called "playoffs" that automatically makes people accept the winner as best?

What if i referred to what we have now as a 2-team playoff, would that make everyone accept the winner?

 

[FirstTimer]

So just because its called "playoffs" that automatically makes people accept the winner as best?

No. Because it's an actual playoff it will.

Don't eat the cat.

What if i referred to what we have now as a 2-team playoff, would that make everyone accept the winner?

No. That would just make you stupid.

 

[ZoneBlitz]

No. Because it's an actual playoff it will.

Oh i see.

So lets say Alabama barely squeaks by a pretty worthless team in the 1st round, while LSU romps...

Then they meet for the title, and Bama wins....everyone would accept Bama as champ? Their weak playoff win would be enough to sway the mind of everyone who had LSU>Bama?

 

[FirstTimer]

Oh i see.

Do you?

Because I see more writing below..........

So lets say Alabama barely squeaks by a pretty worthless team in the 1st round

.............I wasn't aware a "worthless" team would qualify for this playoff of 4 teams. How did Akron get a bid?

 

[FirstTimer]

LOL at ZoneBlitz coming up with idiotic scenarios to try and prove a point.

THis 4 team playoff would have a worthless team in it! ZOMG!

:whut:

 

[ZoneBlitz]

.............I wasn't aware a "worthless" team would qualify for this playoff of 4 teams. How did Akron get a bid?

Hypothetical situation where the 3 & 4 seeds arent that good.

I dont see why each team beating a playoff opponent is enough to sway everyone from LSU>Bama to Bama>LSU.

It actually doesnt make sense.

Im so right that its blows your mind, i forgive you for not being as smart as me.

 

[ram29jackson]

no one cares who wins this game no matter who's in it anyway..after a conference championship, bowl season is just bowl season..the schools get money,the players get grab bags full of stuff and we get football to watch..until theres a real playoff,its just college football bowl fun

 

[FirstTimer]

Hypothetical situation where the 3 & 4 seeds arent that good.

lulz.

So basically grasping at straws at this point.

I don't recall a year ever..in the history of college football where the #3 and #4 teams were seen as "not that good".

Your example means squat.

 

[ZoneBlitz]

lulz.

So basically grasping at straws at this point.

I don't recall a year ever..in the history of college football where the #3 and #4 teams were seen as "not that good".

Your example means squat.

Im trying to come up with examples that show you how wrong you are...the regular example i was using should do that but you're too stupid to get it.

 

[FirstTimer]

Im trying to come up with examples that show you how wrong you are

So an example of something that has never happened or been percieved in college football is the way to do it?

:michaelscott:

 

[ZoneBlitz]

So an example of something that has never happened or been percieved in college football is the way to do it?

:michaelscott:

OK my bad then.

Sticking to the regular example:

If Bama and LSU each beat a quality playoff opponent...why is that enough to sway everyone from LSU>Bama to Bama>LSU??