Game of Thrones

[Villain]

Handicapped brother forces sex upon his sister next to the dead body of their dead incestual aristocratic love child.

Because Game of Thrones.

:kanye:

:duh:

 

[NAHSTE]

I mean, this is the same show where a girl lets her brother finger blast as a practical joke when he doesn't know it's her ... so ... par for the course in 'steros

:notbad:

 

[seaplus]

in your opinion, was Cersei raped?

 

[Bane]

in your opinion, was Cersei raped?

overall no, she obviously was into it towards the end. it was just the location/the idea of being easily caught that turned her off.

 

[NAHSTE]

in your opinion, was Cersei raped?

In my opinion, what was depicted on screen was a rape, yes. Editor or director, or both, botched the execution. Sounds like they intended for it to come across much less rapey based on interviews.

http://www.avclub.com/article/georg...ocialMarketing&utm_campaign=Default:1:Default

 

[SethMode]

In my opinion, what was depicted on screen was a rape, yes. Editor or director, or both, botched the execution. Sounds like they intended for it to come across much less rapey based on interviews.

http://www.avclub.com/article/georg...ocialMarketing&utm_campaign=Default:1:Default

I think she was into it by the end, but it was definitely pretty rapey before that. I am of the opinion that the book segment was pretty rapey too though (we only get Jaime's perspective, after all). Overall, they definitely took a swing and a miss on trying to show what was one of the more disturbing moments of the books.

Still, I read some ludicrous article on Jezebel (shocker, there), about blah blah blah this was despicable blah blah blah. Give me a break. 1) worse is discussed and occurs constantly in the books; and 2) what is with the response to this show seemingly behaving as if the characters are real every Monday morning? This is still a fantasy story, right?

 

[Houston]

Well if ever there was a woman who deserved to get raped....

:running:

 

[NAHSTE]

 

[KINGOFOOTBALL]

overall no, she obviously was into it towards the end. it was just the location/the idea of being easily caught that turned her off.

I took it more as this also. She didnt want to be seen. However recent activity makes me think it it had to be more rapey for him to be trying to establish some control and dominance again.

 

[NAHSTE]

I took it more as this also. She didnt want to be seen. However recent activity makes me think it it had to be more rapey for him to be trying to establish some control and dominance again.

That's how it should have played out. IMO I think they did a very poor job of conveying that.

 

[SethMode]

Listening to a podcast about the episode, and it seems to echo similar sentiments to the rest of the internet. The most irritating thing about this though (and even some other things that I've read) is that everyone is so mortified by this scene, yet I have heard the absolutely random village MASSACRE and presumed EATING of a child's family and village has been described as "amazingly done". 'Murica baby: violence rules.

 

[Kuzzy Powers]

As creepy as the scene was I didnt really take it as a rape scene, more just Sersei resisting, because well... it was beside the dead body of their son.. but actually really wanting her King to be Slayed. :dance3:

 

[NAHSTE]

Listening to a podcast about the episode, and it seems to echo similar sentiments to the rest of the internet. The most irritating thing about this though (and even some other things that I've read) is that everyone is so mortified by this scene, yet I have heard the absolutely random village MASSACRE and presumed EATING of a child's family and village has been described as "amazingly done". 'Murica baby: violence rules.

I agree that those who are taking issue with it on grounds of it being distasteful or repulsive should have probably stopped watching the show a long time ago. The ones who are just mad because their precious Jaime redemption arc has become less black and white, well ... they can kick rocks.

It's a slight characterization change, sure, but this is the same character who tried to murder an 8 year old (after being caught having incestuous sex with very same woman, of course). He can still be #layered and have shades of #grey. I have to agree with a twitter comment I saw that said GRRM had whitewashed Jaime almost too much in the books.

 

[Pitty]

As creepy as the scene was I didnt really take it as a rape scene, more just Sersei resisting, because well... it was beside the dead body of their son.. but actually really wanting her King to be Slayed. :dance3:

That was a rape scene.

 

[Trmszczykowski]

Listening to a podcast about the episode, and it seems to echo similar sentiments to the rest of the internet. The most irritating thing about this though (and even some other things that I've read) is that everyone is so mortified by this scene, yet I have heard the absolutely random village MASSACRE and presumed EATING of a child's family and village has been described as "amazingly done". 'Murica baby: violence rules.

It may seem like a double standard but the "rape" scene went against Jamie's redemption arc. It seemed out of character, meanwhile I was happy with the Wildling/Thenn raids because that's what we're supposed to expect from them, They're big, mean, and scary, and they acted like it.

 

[NAHSTE]

It may seem like a double standard but the "rape" scene went against Jamie's redemption arc. It seemed out of character, meanwhile I was happy with the Wildling/Thenn raids because that's what we're supposed to expect from them, They're big, mean, and scary, and they acted like it.

Right so it's Jaime apologists who can't handle that he's a bad person. Cool.

 

[Trmszczykowski]

Right so it's Jaime apologists who can't handle that he's a bad person. Cool.

HE'S JUST MISUNDERSTOOD!~!~!

 

[SethMode]

It may seem like a double standard but the "rape" scene went against Jamie's redemption arc. It seemed out of character, meanwhile I was happy with the Wildling/Thenn raids because that's what we're supposed to expect from them, They're big, mean, and scary, and they acted like it.

This perspective annoys me. What "redemption" arc? The one you decided that Jaime should have? I hate to break it to you, but the source material of Jaime Lannister is not a nice man. He is trying very hard to become an honorable man, but he at times (as a POV character) straight up admits to himself that he's kind of a piece of shit. These characters are ever changing in the books, and many have multiple hills and valleys as far as what is expected of good and evil characters. You don't spend one jaunt through the woods with a tall chick and become a good guy. It just doesn't happen. It's why the characters in this story are 10x better than 95% of the fantasy nonsense available.

 

[Atlas]

even in westeros, no means yes and yes means anal :smughard:

 

[Fappin Raptor]

I said the same things you guys are saying about Jamie on reddit and got downvoted to oblivion. I'm posting here from now on. :yup: