Johnny Manziel Wowing Them at Manning Camp

[Argath]

Says Manziel won't get drafted.. Compares him to worse QB who was drafted

:dd:

 

[Aso]

Why are we reluctant to look at where he may be drafted after his freshman year? Hasn't Manziel said he plans to come out after this season....

Says Manziel won't get drafted.. Compares him to worse QB who was drafted

:dd:

You must've not read my post.

Besides what does "worse" mean? Worse college QB? That means little to nothing when translating these QBs game to the NFL.

 

[Goober]

This has been another NFL thread successfully ruined by asoraiders.

Good stuff VSN. Jk.

 

[Argath]

Why are we reluctant to look at where he may be drafted after his freshman year? Hasn't Manziel said he plans to come out after this season....



You must've not read my post.

Besides what does "worse" mean? Worse college QB? That means little to nothing when translating these QBs game to the NFL.

As in not as good

 

[Aso]

As in not as good

Being "not as good" a college QB when it comes to the NFL draft and the pros means zilch.

Ask Jason White and Colt Brennan.

 

[Argath]

Being "not as good" a college QB when it comes to the NFL draft and the pros means zilch.

Ask Jason White and Colt Brennan.

Why are you even comparing him to Colt Brennan when they have nothing in common?


Your argument is essentially "Well this QB failed to make it in the NFL so he's got no chance"

 

[Aso]

Why are you even comparing him to Colt Brennan when they have nothing in common?


Your argument is essentially "Well this QB failed to make it in the NFL so he's got no chance"

Your reading comprehension is painfully terrible.

The point is that they are both great college QBs so to say Barkley is "worse" than Manziel so its foolish to cite Barkley when judging Manziel is stupid. Thats black and white thinking and its retarded. Manziel is a better college QB so he must be drafted higher. Mmkay.

:dd:

My argument is what I posted. The only thing I compared between them was their ability to throw short and intermediate passes with great success. But if you want to go further Barkley has the physical look of an NFL QB while Manziel is small... really small and durability should be an obvious concern at his size when you add in he's a running QB as well not to mention he'll have the obstacle of having to see over the line and find passing lanes. To me it looks like he was a weaker arm than Barkley which was criticism of Barkley going into the draft. If you compare them and use Barkley as a reference then I don't see how Manziel looks like a first round pick.

Instead of an intelligent rebuttal you say no Manziels better. Ok I guess you got me then. Case closed.

 

[Argath]

Your reading comprehension is painfully terrible.

The point is that they are both great college QBs so to say Barkley is "worse" than Manziel so its foolish to cite Barkley when judging Manziel is stupid. Thats black and white thinking and its retarded. Manziel is a better college QB so he must be drafted higher. Mmkay.

:dd:

My argument is what I posted. The only thing I compared between them was their ability to throw short and intermediate passes with great success. But if you want to go further Barkley has the physical look of an NFL QB while Manziel is small... really small and durability should be an obvious concern at his size when you add in he's a running QB as well not to mention he'll have the obstacle of having to see over the line and find passing lanes. To me it looks like he was a weaker arm than Barkley which was criticism of Barkley going into the draft. If you compare them and use Barkley as a reference then I don't see how Manziel looks like a first round pick.

Instead of an intelligent rebuttal you say no Manziels better. Ok I guess you got me then. Case closed.

Calls out poster on reading comprehension

Can't comprehend the difference between Barkley and Brennan

:dd:

 

[Aso]

Calls out poster on reading comprehension

Can't tell the difference between Barkley and Brennan when reading

:dd:

I told the difference just fine. Are you really still having trouble?

I'll write everything out for you.

Being a "great" college QB means squat when guys like Jason White and Colt Brennan were considered some of the best and flamed out pretty quickly in the pros. So citing Manziel being a "better" college QB as a reason why a Barkley-Manziel comparison is invalid is retarded.

Do you understand now?

 

[Aso]

and lol at argaths edit. Huge difference between "Can't tell the difference between Barkley and Brennan when reading" and "Can't comprehend the difference between Barkley and Breenan".

:lol:

Oh Argath. Your edit couldn't save you.

 

[Argath]

I told the difference just fine. Are you really still having trouble?

I'll write everything out for you.

Being a "great" college QB means squat when guys like Jason White and Colt Brennan were considered some of the best and flamed out pretty quickly in the pros. So citing Manziel being a "better" college QB as a reason why a Barkley-Manziel comparison is invalid is retarded.

Do you understand now?

Please reread the thread and point where I even made a Barkley-Manziel comparison.

Reading Comprehension. Know it, learn it, use it

 

[Aso]

Please reread the thread and point where I even made a Barkley-Manziel comparison.

Reading Comprehension. Know it, learn it, use it

You didn't, I did and then you criticized the comparison.

The fuck is wrong with you?

 

[Argath]

and lol at argaths edit. Huge difference between "Can't tell the difference between Barkley and Brennan when reading" and "Can't comprehend the difference between Barkley and Breenan".

:lol:

Oh Argath. Your edit couldn't save you.

:facepalm: I was just condensing what I said in hopes it made more sense to you which apparently it didn't. I never said two words about Barkley, i was talking about your fucking ridiculous comparison between Brennan and Manziel. So you can keep debating this imaginary comparison I made.

Carry on.

 

[Argath]

You didn't, I did and then you criticized the comparison.

The fuck is wrong with you?

No I made a joke about your comparison between Brennan and Manziel. Holy fucking shit I never knew people could even be this retarded. Please tell me you dropped out of high school after freshman year so I can atleast have some pitty for you

 

[Aso]

If you swap out Brennan then its still an equally as retarded statement. Referencing how a QB is better in college to someone else as to why they'll be drafted higher... Does anything else really need to be said?

How about we bring up the Wrath thread about how Kevin Kolb was a better college QB than McNabb.

 

[Argath]

:forgetit:

 

[Aso]

Says Manziel won't get drafted.. Compares him to worse QB who was drafted

:dd:

:forgetit:

And the comparison I made between Brennan and Manziel wasn't one regarding direct draft position between the two so your post has little significance. I wasn't saying Brennan went low so Manziel must as well. Your posts are just off the mark entirely.

And I never said Manziel won't get drafted.

:wtf2:

 

[Argath]

You mean if he gets drafted.

Guess what, Colt Brennan played some really good college football too.

Says Manziel won't get drafted.. Compares him to worse QB who was drafted

:dd:

:shiftybones:

 

[Aso]

:shiftybones:

Yes I said if he does. I never said he won't. But you obviously don't see a difference. The point is him getting drafted or drafted high isn't a given as everyone thinks.

And the Colt Brennan comment meant that just because he played great in college he won't get drafted high or higher than players who might have been "worse" as you say in college.

I can't believe after all these posts you're still clueless.

 

[Argath]

Yes I said if he does. I never said he won't. But you obviously don't see a difference. The point is him getting drafted or drafted high isn't a given as everyone thinks.

And the Colt Brennan comment meant that just because he played great in college he won't get drafted high or higher than players who might have been "worse" as you say in college.

I can't believe after all these posts you're still clueless.

:michaelscott:


:mindblown:

:forgetit: