Bad things
1. Clunky gameplay from GTA and RDR. It's just hard to move around and do the things you want to do sometimes.
2. Sometimes the interrogation decisions aren't very clear, even after you found out how you were supposed to answer. They should have set up your responses conversationally instead of just the three categories of responses. I'm not saying make it easy, I just want to know what my guy is going to say when I choose a response.
Overall, I like it but I'm not enamored with Rockstar making the game. I think this game would be better if it used Mass Effect's game engine and conversation system but then again I don't think Bioware could create an atmosphere like Rockstar can.