Playing this game right now I'm probably 1/2 through the vice desk.
Pros:
Interesting game mechanic
Interesting setting
Cons:
-Too much handholding. I turned off auto-aim, turned off the clue music helpers, the clue hints, action skip etc. and it still feels like they're holding my hand throughout the game.
-Too linear, can't really fail, just get different case ratings.
-Side missions are repetitive. Don't like the hidden cars I've found and have no idea how to keep them even if I like one. So I've just been letting my partner drive.
-A lot of the time if I choose doubt or lie he'll say something completely off the wall I didn't expect.
Solid probably like a 7/10. Better rental than buy. Instead of focusing so much on an open world I wish they would've made the cases more open instead.