Polamalu or Ed Reed?

[Bmore]

Troy is the more dominant complete player. If Ed doesn't have the ball in his hands, he's useless.

With your logic I guess Darren Sharper has been the best safety in the past-decade, and that Brian Russell a few years ago was the best safety in the league.

\\

Darren Sharper has been one of the best safeties in the past decade...



BTW That is so fuckin' funny cuz

*drum roll*

Rodney Harrison on Ed Reed

Rodney Told Ed Reed he was the best safety to ever play the game. Click the link and watch the video.

 

[shag773]

It's six in one hand, half a dozen in the other.

 

[davie]

It's six in one hand, half a dozen in the other.

It's six in one pair of hands, and just an interception in the other.

Ed Reed, as well as being a better defensive player, scores TDs.

 

[davie]

Troy is the more dominant complete player. If Ed doesn't have the ball in his hands, he's useless.

With your logic I guess Darren Sharper has been the best safety in the past-decade, and that Brian Russell a few years ago was the best safety in the league.

I'm sorry that the Ravens have a D where the first 10 guys can stop the run and aren't required to make as many tackles. My logic is sound, turnovers are one of the most valuable statistics. Tard.

 

[KoRnStARr]

\\

Darren Sharper has been one of the best safeties in the past decade...



BTW That is so fuckin' funny cuz

*drum roll*

Rodney Harrison on Ed Reed

Rodney Told Ed Reed he was the best safety to ever play the game. Click the link and watch the video.

Weird, because Rodney Harrison said this, this past Sunday on NFL NBC football in America show!

 

[KoRnStARr]

It's six in one pair of hands, and just an interception in the other.

Ed Reed, as well as being a better defensive player, scores TDs.

Really? Has he done it in such a big stage like this?

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LEAnXQth3gU"]YouTube - Troy Polamalu runs back interception for a touchdown (AFC Championship Game)[/ame]

Troy creates more chaos and is in on every play, Ed mean while is sitting playing cover 1 center fielder every rip.

 

[KoRnStARr]

I'm sorry that the Ravens have a D where the first 10 guys can stop the run and aren't required to make as many tackles. My logic is sound, turnovers are one of the most valuable statistics. Tard.

The Steelers personnel is also very sound, you're making yourself look silly. Troy simply does more and is asked to do more because he's the more versatile player who's more dominant in ALL aspects of the game.

 

[davie]

Really? Has he done it in such a big stage like this?

YouTube - Troy Polamalu runs back interception for a touchdown (AFC Championship Game)

Troy creates more chaos and is in on every play, Ed mean while is sitting playing cover 1 center fielder every rip.

Well done, Troy Polamalu picked off a rookie QB who needed to make a play.

The Steelers personnel is also very sound, you're making yourself look silly. Troy simply does more and is asked to do more because he's the more versatile player who's more dominant in ALL aspects of the game.

Why bother creating a poll if you've already decided the answer?

Take your long hair faggot loving self off a bridge.

 

[Archer]

The Steelers personnel is also very sound, you're making yourself look silly. Troy simply does more and is asked to do more because he's the more versatile player who's more dominant in ALL aspects of the game.

Maybe he should do less and he would manage to you know ...... play 16 games every season

Sanders tries to do more than Troy and Reed combined when he plays and look what happens to him?

No need to overcomplicate roles - Rex Ryan

 

[KoRnStARr]

Well done, Troy Polamalu picked off a rookie QB who needed to make a play.



Why bother creating a poll if you've already decided the answer?

Take your long hair faggot loving self off a bridge.

This is the response I expected from a guy with no true rebuttal. It's okay man, not everyone knows what they're talking about. You're no different then 95% of the guys on this site.

 

[KoRnStARr]

Maybe he should do less and he would manage to you know ...... play 16 games every season

Sanders tries to do more than Troy and Reed combined when he plays and look what happens to him?

No need to overcomplicate roles - Rex Ryan

Sanders isn't asked to do as much, the difference with Sanders is he's injury-prone and has a smaller frame then the two.

Troy got hurt off a fluke play, these things do happen.

 

[Archer]

Sanders isn't asked to do as much, the difference with Sanders is he's injury-prone and has a smaller frame then the two.

Troy got hurt off a fluke play, these things do happen.

Sanders isin't asked to do as much lol? He is asked to be in the box as our main run stopper while being able to drop back if they audible to a pass

Sanders attempts to do more than both safetys out there .... and that + his frame costs him

 

[KoRnStARr]

Sanders isin't asked to do as much lol? He is asked to be in the box as our main run stopper while being able to drop back if they audible to a pass

Sanders attempts to do more than both safetys out there .... and that + his frame costs him

He isn't asked to do as much in his scheme then Polamalu is asked to do.

Not sure how he'll be utilized this year as the Colts are running a slightly different style of D.

 

[Archer]

He isn't asked to do as much in his scheme then Polamalu is asked to do.

Not sure how he'll be utilized this year as the Colts are running a slightly different style of D.

I agree on that but I am sure most can agree he does try to do more .

 

[davie]

This is the response I expected from a guy with no true rebuttal. It's okay man, not everyone knows what they're talking about. You're no different then 95% of the guys on this site.

I provided stats to back up my argument. You've sat here and said "Troy is more dominant", "Troy is asked to do more", "Troy has longer hair" blah blah blah blah blah. Tell Troy to make more telling plays.

 

[KoRnStARr]

I provided stats to back up my argument. You've sat here and said "Troy is more dominant", "Troy is asked to do more", "Troy has longer hair" blah blah blah blah blah. Tell Troy to make more telling plays.

To make more telling plays?

His BIG PLAYS have propelled the Steelers to two superbowls. What have Ed's done? Fact of the matter is Troy's big plays are more memorable then Ed's, as his were done in vein.

You have 0 football I.Q., sorry. Not because that you think Ed is better, but you're reasoning/logic and ignorance on Troy and defenses in general.

 

[davie]

To make more telling plays?

His BIG PLAYS have propelled the Steelers to two superbowls. What have Ed's done? Fact of the matter is Troy's big plays are more memorable then Ed's, as his were done in vein.

You have 0 football I.Q., sorry. Not because that you think Ed is better, but you're reasoning/logic and ignorance on Troy and defenses in general.

I give you stats, you give me opinionated words. You have 0 football I.Q.

YAY a pointless argument!

 

[Bmore]

To make more telling plays?

His BIG PLAYS have propelled the Steelers to two superbowls. What have Ed's done? Fact of the matter is Troy's big plays are more memorable then Ed's, as his were done in vein.

You have 0 football I.Q., sorry. Not because that you think Ed is better, but you're reasoning/logic and ignorance on Troy and defenses in general.

Actually the only play Troy has made that I can remember is the INT he got off Flacco last year.

Ed Reed set the longest INT and then beat the record last year against philly, both memorable plays. Portis fumble last season, Punt return for a td against the bengals.

 

[KoRnStARr]

Actually the only play Troy has made that I can remember is the INT he got off Flacco last year.

Ed Reed set the longest INT and then beat the record last year against philly, both memorable plays. Portis fumble last season, Punt return for a td against the bengals.

Selective memory, his INT on the Chargers was one of the greatest INTs of all time

 

[Bmore]

Selective memory, his INT on the Chargers was one of the greatest INTs of all time

Hypocrite.