Warner2BruceTD
2011 Poster Of The Year
Hey biss, how long has Archibald Peck/RD Evans been around for you guys in Anarchy?
There is a debate over on the Meltzer board concerning his rookie status for the 2011 Awards. The standard used is the wrestler could not have debuted prior to September 1, 2010 in a "full time" promotion.
Some are arguing that ACW should count as a "full time promotion", others are not. I assume he's been around since long before 9/1/10 for you guys.
He started with CHIKARA during the voting period, but was with ROH prior to the voting period I believe (although not really as a wrestler, as I don't even recall a single match). Everyone considers those two full time promotions, but it's fuzzy anyway because he isn't really a wrestler for ROH. He would qualify for his CHIKARA work assuming ACW doesn't count. It's a mess.
I guess long story short would be this: a.) Do you consider ACW a "full time promotion", and b.) if so, when did he start?
I think Shiya Hashimoto's kid is going to run away with Rookie of the Year anyway, but there is a lot of support for Archibald Peck, and CHIKARA had a big year so I think he can place pretty high. He is getting a lot of support for "Best Gimmick", too.
There is a debate over on the Meltzer board concerning his rookie status for the 2011 Awards. The standard used is the wrestler could not have debuted prior to September 1, 2010 in a "full time" promotion.
Some are arguing that ACW should count as a "full time promotion", others are not. I assume he's been around since long before 9/1/10 for you guys.
He started with CHIKARA during the voting period, but was with ROH prior to the voting period I believe (although not really as a wrestler, as I don't even recall a single match). Everyone considers those two full time promotions, but it's fuzzy anyway because he isn't really a wrestler for ROH. He would qualify for his CHIKARA work assuming ACW doesn't count. It's a mess.
I guess long story short would be this: a.) Do you consider ACW a "full time promotion", and b.) if so, when did he start?
I think Shiya Hashimoto's kid is going to run away with Rookie of the Year anyway, but there is a lot of support for Archibald Peck, and CHIKARA had a big year so I think he can place pretty high. He is getting a lot of support for "Best Gimmick", too.