They should do a Tough Enough with experienced "name" indy workers. Don't get me wrong, I love laughing at these bafoons they found, but I think a show with all high end talent would be really interesting. Of course, every single thing they do is tho opposite of what I like, so what do I know?
I thought this similarly.
But, lets be honest...what can Stone Cold, Booker T, and Trish Stratus teach Austin Aries, Sara Del Rey, Chris Hero, etc. and why would I want to see these guys, all of which can work, take bumps and run ropes and then play intramural basketball?
They did a Tough Enough with Indy guys, and it was called NXT. Most of the NXT guys were Indy guys, or "FCW-talent"...Danielson, Low Ki, Barrett, Ryan Reeves, Hennig and Rotundo, Slater and Gabriel.
If you want to see Tough Enough with Indy guys, there you go.
A "Tough Enough" with Trainers Jim Ross, Michael Cole, Jessie Ventura, and Bobby Heenan with talent like BigBiss and Larry Sweeney might be worth the lulz though. Be the next voice of the WWE.