Enough is enough. Peyton Manning is the greatest QB of all time.

[KNUBB]

I'm a big fan of this one

So, basically, we're in agreement. Drew Brees is an average quarterback, who needs a superior supporting cast, before he's able to win anything?

That's been my point all along.

He's not a top 5 NFL quarterback.

The top 5 NFL quarterbacks get the job done with what they have.

[KNUBB]

Your "hypocrit" post came directly after a post I made responding to you.(Again)

Get your head out of your ass.

Check the post times numb nuts. We posted at the same time. I didn't even see your post until after I submitted mine.

[KNUBB]

Also your groans don't hurt me cause I'm SUPER POWERFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[FirstTimer]

I'm a big fan of this one

at you taking Nuk seriously.

Also you said "hypocrites" plural. Who were these hypocrites you were speaking of?

[Bear Pand]

You know how you cunts used to say that Drew Brees threw his team out of games when it was crunch time? Well how in the fuck you give Manning a pass. Use the same logic that you use on every other QB. Don't make excuses for the man considered G.O.A.T. JTC is right. Brady did go to the AFC championship game with JABAR FUCKING GAFFNEY AND RECHE CALDWELL. Don't deflect the blame. You all want to give all the success to the QB now is the time to give the blame to the QB.

Why is Brees even being mentioned in this thread? And I say this as a Purdue alum.

Also I'd trade the team and coaching staff that Brady went to that AFC CG with for what the Colts have now, easily. It's not even close. The Colts are a mess right now. Manning INTs or not they aren't doing shit this season.

[KNUBB]

:youmad:

[KNUBB]

Why is Brees even being mentioned in this thread? And I say this as a Purdue alum.

Also I'd trade the team and coaching staff that Brady went to that AFC CG with for what the Colts have now, easily. It's not even close. The Colts are a mess right now. Manning INTs or not they aren't doing shit this season.

Brees was brought up to make the point of the people like to place all of the blame on the QB but in this case Mr. Manning is getting the free pass

[FirstTimer]

:youmad:

No.

Just amused by your never ending idiocy.

[KNUBB]

You're like ram29jackson on this one. I think you have yet to make a point to disprove what I have said, but rather stick with the old "I'm smarter than you tactic". It's not gonna work today son.

[FirstTimer]

You're like ram29jackson on this one. I think you have yet to make a point to disprove what I have said, but rather stick with the old "I'm smarter than you tactic". It's not gonna work today son.

You've said something on the subject?

All I've seen you do so far is get butt hurt over Drew Brees.

I'm not going to defend or excuse anything anyone else has said. Only what I have and you have jack shit on me. I have not given Manning a free pass and haven't said anything that could be taken as such. My obvious initial point was that it's a bit much to say Manning is hitting some sort of age bound wall when you actually look at what he's doing in context of the team around him.


Meanwhile you're upset over something Nuk said about Drew Brees nearly two years ago.

Nice work.

[shag773]

2. Manning I have ahead of him because he is pretty much lapping the field statistically even in this era and is winning a massive amount of games. Montana didn't really set the standard. Guys like Starr, Luckman, Bradshaw, Graham, etc all had long stretches of championship success before Montana came along. Montana was next in line but let's not pretend Montana was the first QB of a dynasty to win multiple ships on some good/great teams.


If you want to put Montana at #1 then that's fine. You'd have a strong argument to do so but I think for anyone to just act as though there aren't some other REALLY good candidates or guys that coul dmake equally good if not better cases for the spot is just not true.

1. I never said he was the first, just the best.

2. I never said there weren't other really good candidates, I can appreciate other people's stance and see where they are coming from. Just because I disagree with you it doesn't make your points invalid.

[Senser81]

I'm a big fan of this one

Knubb...no one really put any merit into what Nuk said. I remember before Drew Brees, Nuk had it in for Rich Gannon. Week after week of Nuk proclaiming that Gannon was "overrated" and a "jerk" ended with the Raiders going to the Super Bowl. When they lost to the Bucs, Nuk said "see? told you so".

Brees is really good. Manning has been better for a longer period of time. Thats my simple take on it.

[KNUBB]

You've said something on the subject?

All I've seen you do so far is get butt hurt over Drew Brees.

I'm not going to defend or excuse anything anyone else has said. Only what I have and you have jack shit on me. I have not given Manning a free pass and haven't said anything that could be taken as such. My obvious initial point was that it's a bit much to say Manning is hitting some sort of age bound wall when you actually look at what he's doing in context of the team around him.


Meanwhile you're upset over something Nuk said about Drew Brees nearly two years ago.

Nice work.

LOL @ butthurt of Brees

Saints are 9-3 and are in fine position

and me upset? not even in the slightest. You really must be mad

[KNUBB]

Also I know Nuk is a troll.I knew he wasn't serious. It was the others who joined in with him and co-signed

[FirstTimer]

1. I never said he was the first, just the best.

I guess I took you saying Montana "set the bar" as you saying he was the first.