Enough is enough. Peyton Manning is the greatest QB of all time.

[Houston]

How is this even a discussion?

[Warner2BruceTD]

How is this even a discussion?

Astounding, isn't it?

[Herm]

Topic from 2009? How many site mergers and ownership changes did this cockroach outlive?

[Warner2BruceTD]

throwing 55 td's and 5500 yard in todays game does not make him the goat.

Absolutely true. Completely agree.

He was already the best QB of all time when I made this thread four years ago.

Much like sex over 20 minutes, now he's just showing off.

[JimLeavy59]

Oh fuck the ring argument. Anyone who says or types "Peyton Manning is the greatest regular season quarterback of all time but when it comes playoff time" is admitting that instead of watching games they just let Sportscenter tell them what to think. And they think First Take truly embraces debate.

[Maynard]

How is this even a discussion?

its a discussion because people like you have invalid opinions. which is why you have nothing to add.

btw rams, Jerry and John were only with Joe for 2 of the 4 SB...prior to that it was Clark, and Solomon...Clark had 2 All Pro years and Freddie had none....but the main guy was Craig. Even the goat has to have good players to throw to.

[Maynard]

Oh fuck the ring argument. Anyone who says or types "Peyton Manning is the greatest regular season quarterback of all time but when it comes playoff time" is admitting that instead of watching games they just let Sportscenter tell them what to think. And they think First Take truly embraces debate.

there is no doubt he is great, but he is not the greatest of all time...sorry

[CaribbeanJoseph]

Elway is the GOAT

[Houston]

its a discussion because people like you have invalid opinions. which is why you have nothing to add.

I only debate or discuss with those on my level. To everyone below, I teach.

[Maynard]

I only debate or discuss with those on my level. To everyone below, I teach.

seeing we have no 5 year olds on the site, it explains why you never have anything to say

[Glenbino]

Tim Tebow still has more playoff wins than him as a Bronco

[JeremyHight]

It may be unfair, I don't really care, but when you are talking about GOATs, you are going to split hairs. And Manning has a GOLIATH hair that is his record and performances in the playoffs. I know he isn't done yet, but so far, he is not going to pass by Montana until he starts playing consistently great in the playoffs like Montana did.

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

I'd still put him third.

Montana
Elway
Manning

[JeremyHight]

I'd say its more like

Montana
.
.
.
.
.
Manning
.
Rest of the elite level QBs (Elway, Unitas, Brady, etc.)

[PP]

Manning and Elway aren't in the same sentence. Elway never pissed down his leg in playoff games.