Eli Manning...

[ralaw]

Big Ben to Holmes for game winning TD > that throw.

That happened in the past.....don't remember. Right now, because it happened yesterday it is the best throw evar!!!11!

 

[FirstTimer]

the frist drive and last drive = 2 mins of a 60 min game

Umm what about Brady getting kocked around the entire first quarter to the point where I think the Giants had a 22 to 6 advantage TOP advantage towards the end of the first half.

I thought the Giants pass rush was pretty good all game. They were some spots where it wasn't great but overall I was impressed. Brady got knocked around pretty good in the first quarter and first part of the 2nd quarter and later in the game.

 

[Houston]

You're sucking awful in this thread, as Warner said. Both QB's essentially put up the same amount of points, one is labeled great and one is labeled poor. Horrific logic because they just see the "W" at the end.

Clutch throws in superbowl=great
safety in superbowl=poor


Eli Manning had a better performance than Brady, doesn't matter who won the game.

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

LETS DO THIS

Welker was still moving forward at the time. It wasn't a "stop" throw where you throw the WR away from the over the top coverage. He threw him away from the underneath and middle coverage.

You can throw all this worthless detail into the discussion as you want, but its still a Tim Tebow like throw.

Didn't use fruit pop.

Not impressed.

You don't use logic.

Not impressed.

Says the guy who was captaining Eli for the HOF since 2007

:yao:

I look more prophetic by the day.

I have a tiny dick.

Fixed.

:cano:

 

[Primetime]

Welker is a great reciever.. has nothing to do with the quality of the throw lmao...

:joker:

 

[Len B]

I dont really understand your point, Brady played 'great' LOL

That's my point, what don't you understand? lol

Bottom line is opposing fans feel like he gets more credit than he deserves, so when they have an opportunity to say it's Brady's fault they go insanely overboard.

Brady got bailed out vs. Baltimore and shouldn't have even been here this year, and then he got fucked this week vs. Giants. It goes both ways.

 

[Aso]

Welker could've caught that pass in stride over his shoulder. I'm not sure why he did a 180. It was a great throw that Welker made some stupid adjustment to. I don't get why he didn't just keep running and made the catch over his shoulder. Welkers stupid adjustment to the ball made it look like a bad throw.

 

[shag773]

No, I don't lack it all.

The idea that "he will finish Top 15 in yards!" just doesn't mean all that much.

see: Testaverde, Vinny

There are plenty of QBs who will never sniff the hall of fame that will end up in the top 15 statistically because the passing game has become more prominent as the years go on.

So again I ask, lack perspective much?

 

[FirstTimer]

You can throw all this worthless detail into the discussion as you want, but its still a Tim Tebow like throw.

Hyperbole FTW!

You don't use logic.

Not impressed.

Still no use of the words fruit and pop.

I look more prophetic by the day.

Nah. Just dumber.

Fixed.

:cano:

Seems to be hurting Robinson quite a bit.

:smug:

 

[RosettaStoned]

Welker could've caught that pass in stride over his shoulder. I'm not sure why he did a 180.

Because he was running full speed, facing the other fucking way. I feel like none of you have ever fucking worn pads before?

That's a tough catch. Yes he could have caught it, yes he does make great catches all the time and it seems routine... but that was a poorly placed ball.

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

I was hoping it'd drop off the first page, only to resurrect it in 15 years or whenever Eli puts on his gold jacket...

Now when I do that, I now know what skittle loving plebs to throw my dick into.

Just an FYI - prepare thy anus.

wut

 

[Liquidrob]

Welker is a great reciever.. has nothing to do with the quality of the throw lmao...

I would say that is a better combined throw and catch, Holmes made that play special

Manningham was just able to catch it and the big part was getting the feet in, Holmes had to do more, Manning dropped it in perfectly

anyway, if it was Brady throwing it Holmes would have had to be 6'10"

 

[Warner2BruceTD]

There are plenty of QBs who will never sniff the hall of fame that will end up in the top 15 statistically because the passing game has become more prominent as the years go on.

So again I ask, lack perspective much?

Again, I don't lack perspective at all.

The guys who lack perspective are the ones touting the (presumed eventual) numbers of Eli as something special.

You got it backwards, fella.

 

[LiquidLarry2GhostWF]

wut

Remove yourself from this thread and get to work on another write up STAT!

 

[shag773]

I do when both those records give each team two score leads and put points on the board, like a QB should.

You're sucking awful in this thread, as Warner said. Both QB's essentially put up the same amount of points, one is labeled great and one is labeled poor. Horrific logic because they just see the "W" at the end.

:joker:

 

[Len B]

This thread is full of win.

 

[FirstTimer]

Hall of Famer

 

[FedEx227]

Not sure if you saw the Giants final drive or not, you might have been crunching numbers with fellow quasi-stat fruit pop FedEx to discuss greatness at the kids table, but over here at the grown folks table, greatness is determined by achieving great things and doing great things...winning and losing the Super Bowl is the difference between achieving and not achieving great things, throwing that pass to Mario Manningham in this game, in his first Super Bowl, the pass to Tyree...great things...the end result matters, regardless of how its determined and undermining it by who has the ball last, is silly and it couples in with this new found internet idea to try to outsmart yourself in discussing greatness that's ruining baseball discussions involving similar matters. You're taking your 5m morning commute by hovercraft.

:jonesy:

And using ridiculously small sample sizes to dictate your opinions. If Welker doesn't drop a pass, the same people are doing the "IS TOM BRADY THE BEST EVER?".

How about we just look at someones entire body of work?

 

[DJ Rhude]

Someone said that was the best throw ever by Eli

Even an Eli homer like myself is going to have to take the high road on that one.....hard to top Big Ben to Holmes FTSBW

 

[Liquidrob]

That's my point, what don't you understand? lol

Bottom line is opposing fans feel like he gets more credit than he deserves, so when they have an opportunity to say it's Brady's fault they go insanely overboard.

Brady got bailed out vs. Baltimore and shouldn't have even been here this year, and then he got fucked this week vs. Giants. It goes both ways.

how did Brady get 'fucked'

Brady did nothing after the drive in the 3rd, you're really putting it on Welker to make that catch every time?

It's not like Brady had a Doug Williams like 2nd and put up 30+ points, he got them 17 and than nothing for pretty much the 2nd half of the game minus the first drive