Is Kurt Warner a HOF'er?

[MrBill]

His only negative is his taste in women.

Brenda actually doesn't look that bad these days...

As compared to how most of us remember her in the past...

 

[Rayman]

When Nuk made this thread last year, that's when I became a believer.


Well, actually, it was after the Cards' first playoff game that year. But yeah.


oh, and I'd give it to the "new" Brenda

 

[Deviant]

Just as long as the voters don't find/remember this moment of his career, he should get in:

 

[jeffx]

Brenda actually doesn't look that bad these days...

As compared to how most of us remember her in the past...

Okay, she is less scary now(but not by much). But hey, every bitch looks hot when the lights go out.

 

[Tailback U]

I'd fuck the ever living shit out of that jesus worshipping slut.

 

[DJ Rhude]

Just as long as the voters don't find/remember this moment of his career, he should get in:

That failed stint with the Giants wasn't all his fault though

Our O-line back then was referred to as the worst in the entire league....Warner came over to us already beat up and a bit gun shy

He wasn't terrible for us tho, he also didn't set the world on fire....but remember, all the critics said he was washed up after he left the Rams

When he came to us, he was in the process of partially repairing his career, but everyone knew he was just keeping the seat warm for Eli

How he rebounded once he got to Arizona was remarkable IMO...I mean, no one saw that shit coming

I'd be really shocked if he didn't get in

 

[adembroski]

Rightttttttt....

palmer
Brees
Cutler

are all better then Warner.

U disagree? prove it.

Kurt Warner's career
2,666/4,070 (65.5%), 32,344 yards (7.9 ypa), 208 TDs, 128 INTs (93.7 PR)
3 MVP awards
12 post season wins, 3 Superbowl appearances, 1 Superbowl victory
Owns records for highest completion percentage in a single game, passing yards in a Superbowl, Career Superbowl passing yards, most passing yards in a single playoff, highest career completion percentage in the playoffs, highest percentage of 300+ yard games, Most consecutive 300+ yard passing games, Most career games with perfect passer rating, Fastest player to reach 30,000 yards, One of only 2 players with 4 consecutive games with a passer rating over 120.0, one of only 2 players to throw for 5 TDs in 2 playoff games, 3rd QB in history to win a conference championship with 2 different teams

Palmer + Cutler + Brees
5,457/8,570 (63.7%), 62,060 yards (7.24 YPA), 319 TDs (106.3 per), 229 INTs (76.3 per) (86.6 PR)
1 playoff win, 0 Superbowl appearances, 0 MVP awards... although, to be fair, Palmer did win the FedEx Air Player of the Year in 2006
Drew Brees holds the record for most completions in a season and highest completion percentage for a season. Palmer and Culter own a few Bengals and Broncos team records, respectively.

Proven.

 

[FirstTimer]

Kurt Warner's career
2,666/4,070 (65.5%), 32,344 yards (7.9 ypa), 208 TDs, 128 INTs (93.7 PR)
3 MVP awards
12 post season wins, 3 Superbowl appearances, 1 Superbowl victory
Owns records for highest completion percentage in a single game, passing yards in a Superbowl, Career Superbowl passing yards, most passing yards in a single playoff, highest career completion percentage in the playoffs, highest percentage of 300+ yard games, Most consecutive 300+ yard passing games, Most career games with perfect passer rating, Fastest player to reach 30,000 yards, One of only 2 players with 4 consecutive games with a passer rating over 120.0, one of only 2 players to throw for 5 TDs in 2 playoff games, 3rd QB in history to win a conference championship with 2 different teams

Palmer + Cutler + Brees
5,457/8,570 (63.7%), 62,060 yards (7.24 YPA), 319 TDs (106.3 per), 229 INTs (76.3 per) (86.6 PR)
3 playoff wins, 0 Superbowl appearances, 0 MVP awards... although, to be fair, Palmer did win the FedEx Air Player of the Year in 2006
Drew Brees holds the record for most completions in a season and highest completion percentage for a season. Palmer and Culter own a few Bengals and Broncos team records, respectively.

Proven.

Owned...

You're both owned.

He was being sarcastic.

 

[Nukleopatra]

I'm just wondering where Adem got those two extra playoff victories from.

Jay Cutler has never been.
Crapson Palmer has none.
Drew Brees has 1 playoff win in 8 seasons.

How does that equal three?

 

[jeffx]

I'd fuck the ever living shit out of that jesus worshipping slut.

"Pretend I'm Jesus - now get on your knees bitch, and eat from the body of Christ!"

 

[KINGOFOOTBALL]

Warner has had 6 great seasons.
6 shit fest/nowhere to be found seasons.

His great seasons and whats hes done on 2 different teams is remarkable. His playoff performances are easily HOF worthy.

I thought before the playoffs last year he'd need SB win for hof status. He played admirably enough that he still elevated himself significantly.

Hes unquestionably NOT a first ballot HOFer. If you think he deserves it the same as Manning , Brady , Favre and other in his era you sadly mistaken. You cant disappear for 5 years and think you can wedge yourself into first ballot bid without winning another ring.

Hes got amazing credentials and would not be against or surpised in the least if he ends up in the HOF one day. But unless he wins another ring dont mention first ballott.

 

[Nukleopatra]

first ballott.

He's easily first ballot.

 

[elbingz]

Warner's definitely a HOF'er. I always hated him, but you can't hate on his ability. I'd be surprised if he doesn't get in the first time around. Warren Moon got in first ballot didn't he?

 

[Nukleopatra]

Warner's definitely a HOF'er. I always hated him, but you can't hate on his ability. I'd be surprised if he doesn't get in the first time around. Warren Moon got in first ballot didn't he?

I'd thank you 100 times if I could.

Great example.

 

[FirstTimer]

Warner has had 6 great seasons.
6 shit fest/nowhere to be found seasons.

I count 5 tops.

1999, 2001, 2007, 2008, 2009. Of those 2007 is on the borderline but I will give it to you just for the sake of it. He was 5-6 that year with a QB rating below 90. Tough for me to call it "great"....

 

[killgod]

fuck MaddenMania for closing it's doors.

I want my mega post on Warner's ability to shred 25th or worse ranked pass defences.


like fuckin hell i'm doin all that research again.


Warner impresses me with what he does sometimes, but it's the fucking NFC west for fuck's sake.

 

[FirstTimer]

Warner's definitely a HOF'er. I always hated him, but you can't hate on his ability. I'd be surprised if he doesn't get in the first time around. Warren Moon got in first ballot didn't he?

EDIT* Nevermind*

Even so Moon played in the NFL for 17 years tough to compare him with Warner's 5 very good/ great seasons.

 

[Nukleopatra]

I count 5 tops.

1999, 2001, 2007, 2008, 2009. Of those 2007 is on the borderline but I will give it to you just for the sake of it. He was 5-6 that year with a QB rating below 90. Tough for me to call it "great"....

Warren Moon finished his entire career with an 80 QB rating. He also had 101 career losses, 7 postseason losses, a career completion % under 60, and he's black. He only had two seasons with a QB rating in the 90s.

Oh, and he's black.

 

[elbingz]

EDIT* Nevermind*

Even so Moon played in the NFL for 17 years tough to compare him with Warner's 5 very good/ great seasons.

CFL stats count for the NFL? No.

 

[FirstTimer]

Warren Moon finished his entire career with an 80 QB rating. He also had 101 career losses, 7 postseason losses, a career completion % under 60, and he's black. He only had two seasons with a QB rating in the 90s.

Warner also has played in a much more QB friendly era even in comparison to Moon in the 80's and early 90's.