The OFFICIAL Peyton Manning Sweepstakes thread...

[MrBill]

On Mike and Mike this morning, Adam Schefter said he thinks the Colts will release Manning and draft Luck since nobody will take that contract.

What a bummer to not get anything for him even, terrible move by the Colts to give him that contract when he's had neck issues for a while now.

That would be bad for the Colts. I know old players are nothing but pieces of meat to an organization but get something. The Packers at least got the pick they used to draft Clay Matthews when they traded Favre to the Jets.

 

[Tailback U]

That would be bad for the Colts. I know old players are nothing but pieces of meat to an organization but get something. The Packers at least got the pick they used to draft Clay Matthews when they traded Favre to the Jets.

I agree but let's not act like Manning is a sure fire bet to return 100% healthy and just pick up where has left off.

At some point, you have to start thinking about the 10 years for your franchise instead of the next 1 or 2 so I can see why the Colts might want to trade him.

Otherwise, they aren't going to get another shot at a top QB prospect until Manning retires.

 

[Houston]

What a bummer to not get anything for him even

Fuck the Colts, I'll be glad if they get nothing.


I'd side with Manning any day of the week.

 

[kyhadley]

I agree but let's not act like Manning is a sure fire bet to return 100% healthy and just pick up where has left off.

At some point, you have to start thinking about the 10 years for your franchise instead of the next 1 or 2 so I can see why the Colts might want to trade him.

Otherwise, they aren't going to get another shot at a top QB prospect until Manning retires.

Kind of contradictory statements, if he doesn't pick up where he left off then they could have a shot at another top QB prospect as soon as next year.

 

[Hasselbeck]

Welcome to Seattle Peyton.

 

[Tailback U]

Kind of contradictory statements, if he doesn't pick up where he left off then they could have a shot at another top QB prospect as soon as next year.

Not necessarily. If they get a mid to late round pick chances that they get a legit top prospect QB are pretty slim.

 

[kyhadley]

Not necessarily. If they get a mid to late round pick chances that they get a legit top prospect QB are pretty slim.

That's what I'm saying, if they keep him and he doesn't pick up where he left off they are still a terrible team and could have another early pick next year.

 

[Aso]

I really wish Archie would keep his mouth shut. Let them make their own decisions.

 

[Tailback U]

That's what I'm saying, if they keep him and he doesn't pick up where he left off they are still a terrible team and could have another early pick next year.

What are you talking about? If he picks up where he left off then they win 11 games in the regular season and make it to the playoffs.

If he doesn't then they finish around or below .500.

Yeah, they can draft a QB with the 20th pick in the draft but they are most likely not going to get one of the top prospects and they'd be taking a chance on that player. They'd be better off taking the best player available at a position of need instead.

 

[Derrville]

If Colts trade or release Manning I bet in about 10 years or so were going to be talking about the Manning Curse.

 

[Tailback U]

If Colts trade or release Manning I bet in about 10 years or so were going to be talking about the Manning Curse.

Or we could talk about how the Colts had a chance to draft Andrew Luck 10 years ago but stuck with Manning who ended up retiring midway through the next season because of a blindside hit.

 

[Bear Pand]

None of this matters until it's more clear how healthy he's going to be going forward.

If Indy believes Manning will be healthy it'd be dumb to get rid of him, especially for nothing. If it comes down to a healthy (or close to healthy) Manning or Luck I'd roll with Manning easily.

 

[RainboUnicorn]

Or we could talk about how the Colts had a chance to draft Andrew Luck 10 years ago but stuck with Manning who ended up retiring midway through the next season because of a blindside hit.

uh or we can talk about how Peyton Manning was the greatest QB to ever play the game and Luck turned out to be an average QB/bust.

The thing that bugs me about all this hype around Luck is the fact that these 'experts' are acting like Luck will be able to even sniff Peyton's jock. Luck has played 0 downs in the NFL. Sure he 'looks' NFL ready but he is unproven. Manning is the greatest QB to ever play the game. He has another 5 years once he comes back. Why on earth would you get rid of the greatest quarterback ever on essentially a gamble.

I guarantee in the next 5 years the Colts will be able to find a quarterback in the draft that can succeed Manning. Why go all-in on Luck now?

It honestly boggles my mind that they would even consider it.

The only logical way I think they could think about getting rid of Manning is if his neck really isn't healing. If it is healed then there is no way in hell I draft Luck next year. Not even to sit on my bench behind manning IMO.

I'm laughing even having to type this because there is discussion to get rid of PEYTON MANNING

 

[DSpydr84]

I agree but let's not act like Manning is a sure fire bet to return 100% healthy and just pick up where has left off.

At some point, you have to start thinking about the 10 years for your franchise instead of the next 1 or 2 so I can see why the Colts might want to trade him.

Otherwise, they aren't going to get another shot at a top QB prospect until Manning retires.

Let's not forget though, Luck is not proven at this level. I know he's the hot-hand right now, but this has happened before.

If the Colts drop Manning, and Luck busts, this team is in the whole for the next 10 years.

To me, it doesn't make any sense to get rid of a guy that's gotten you 10-wins consistently every year, and without him they haven't won a game. I really don't even see how it's debatable. Manning at 50% helps this team tremendously, even if it is for three years.

 

[ThunderHorse]

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/...KmIN5UKUI0iy,53cTY0Mzqbx2_bygYkun6UiPZKFsgasM

 

[j.hen]

:jimshake:

Fucking sucks we had to go a whole year of football without this man.

 

[ThunderHorse]

you learn a lot about who's serious about the team and who's not fan wise..

granted, we'll know more in say, 3-4 years given the success/failure possibilities in the future. however I can legitimately say it feels like 97-98 again but worse. sometimes I wonder whether Peyton was the reason the team turned around in 99 or if it was Edgerrin, I tend to go with James simply because the team was hurting bad in 01 when his knee went out on him. we need a guy like that again to take some pressure off of Manning.

Jim Irsay always picks me up with his encouraging tweets though!

in 10 years we went from this

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nq0aXUxfEjs"]Edgerrin James Highlights - YouTube[/ame]

to this

:facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm::facepalm: :facepalm:​

 

[ThunderHorse]

http://www.grantland.com/blog/the-t...pse-of-the-colts-has-been-years-in-the-making

The Colts weren't an elite team before Peyton Manning got injured; they were a middling team propped up by the greatest quarterback in league history. The Old Colts are dead, and neither Andrew Luck nor Peyton Manning can bring them back.

 

[KINGOFOOTBALL]

If Andrew Luck is within reach I may take my chance with him. Colts aren't anywhere near a SB threat. You'd have to spend that no.1 pick and pray itd be an immediate elite player to help manning on either side of the ball. Then pray hed stay healthy. Then pray his body will still hold up long enough for you to groom a replacement.
Thats alot of things that would have to go right. Considering the success guys like Tebow,Newton are having and dont have anywhere near the polish Luck has Id say go with him and get what you can from Manning if he wants out.

I love Manning but hey Montana looked good in Chiefs red maybe Manning will bring some magic to another team and further solidify his rep.

p.s E.James was a beast before his injury. Even his attitude in the run game changed after that.

 

[ZoneBlitz]

http://www.grantland.com/blog/the-t...pse-of-the-colts-has-been-years-in-the-making

Ive said this before, even if Manning played this year, the Colts werent gonna be as good as they had been.