Tom Brady - 63.6% career completion %, 92.9 quarterback rating, 14-2 post season record, 4 super bowl appearances, 3 super bowl victories, 88.0 post season rating.
Peyton Manning - 64.4% career completion %, 94.7 quarterback rating, 7-8 post season record, 1 super bowl appearance, 1 super bowl victory, 84.9 post season rating.
Both quarterbacks are close in every category, except for winning in big games. I'm sorry, but using Peyton Manning's 2008 MVP, where he was kicked out of the playoffs after the very first game, doesn't make Peyton Manning a better quarterback.. It simply means the NFL's decision to choose the MVP before the most important games, is a stupid idea. Tom Brady gets injured for a season, and you people are replacing him with Matt Cassel, who couldn't even lead the team to the playoffs. Some of you really amaze me.
I can't even believe I brought myself into such a stupid fucking argument, so I'll let you guys go back to whatever fantasy land you currently reside in. Have fun.