Peyton Manning should win the Comeback award and it shouldn't even be a debate. He missed an entire season and was tossed aside like trash over concerns about his neck. Six months ago, people were saying he could be facing a career ending and potential paralyzing injury if he stepped back on the field.
MVP, I dont care. You can make a case for any of the guys mentioned in the thread, including Ryan. Much like the stupid Cabrera/Trout debate, none of them are 'wrong'.
Mmmmm.....I don't know about all that. No one knew what he'd be like when/if he came back. Anything contrary is just the usual jumping the gun. Then, if the Colts drafted 10th or 15th, he's suddenly not "tossed aside" anymore. And he got tons of overtures from Miami, Denver, and Arizona, too much to think anyone was calling him trash. It was hardly like Drew Brees being signed by the Saints after everyone else involved said "no thanks".
Peyton is back to where a healthy Peyton is supposed to be, and the media is making it out like his head legit fell off 8 months ago or something. I suppose I shouldn't really expect better, though.