Why Oklahoma State is more deserving of a title shot than Bama

[KNUBB]

Anyone for the rematch is a faggot

:kanye:

 

My 2 cents

 

[NAHSTE]

Just realized I blew my Man Who Would Be King reference. It was Sean Connery's character who claimed all the false titles, ala an Alabama fan.

 

[DSpydr84]

DSpyder,

Humor me and answer this: If Ok St was undefeated(squeaker win over Iowa State) and Alabama had a squeker loss to LSU I'm sure some people would still say Alabama was the second best team.....Do you feel this way?

Thanks,

VSD

In my honest opinion, and this is not bullshit, I would still stay Alabama is the second best team. BUT, and this is important, because Oklahoma St wins the game (and assuming they go on to beat Oklahoma), they would be ranked higher and deserving to play in the National Championship game.

The issue is this: They're all at one loss (except Houston, which I said before causes a whole different mess in itself). Because of that, it levels the playing field in terms of record. So we have to look at who that loss was against.

As I said from the beginning, I think LSU and Alabama are in a class of their own. That's my opinion. The voters have a different opinion. So do you. The problem is it comes down to what we all think, not what happens on the field.

You can call it blind homerism if you want, but I think I've been pretty fair with everything I've said up to this point. I would vouch for LSU if they were in our shoes because I still stand by these two teams as the best in the country. I would also stand by Alabama if they weren't in contention at all (and bitch for a playoff system because they got robbed).

Bottom line: The rankings are/always will be fucked up. Stripping everything away and looking at Team A against Team B, I think the best two teams are LSU and Alabama. And since that is the case, they should compete for the National Championship.

 

[ZoneBlitz]

I would also stand by Alabama if they weren't in contention at all (and bitch for a playoff system because they got robbed).

Many people wouldnt even have Alabama in a playoff, because one of the most popular models is inviting only the conference champs (whether top 6 or all 11).

 

[FirstTimer]

In my honest opinion, and this is not bullshit, I would still stay Alabama is the second best team.

Ok. You can STFU now. Because Ok St losing to Iowa State isn't an issue then.

BUT, and this is important, because Oklahoma St wins the game (and assuming they go on to beat Oklahoma), they would be ranked higher and deserving to play in the National Championship game.

According to you that doesn't matter. All that matters is putting the two best teams in. Ok St being undefeated or not, to you, is immaterial in that regard.

The issue is this: They're all at one loss (except Houston, which I said before causes a whole different mess in itself). Because of that, it levels the playing field in terms of record. So we have to look at who that loss was against.

Yeah but let's ignore who the wins were against at the same time! If not all losses are created equal, not all wins are either.

You can call it blind homerism if you want

More like blind, deaf, and dumb.

,

but I think I've been pretty fair with everything I've said up to this point.

:niggaplease:

You haven't.

It's been awful.

 

[DSpydr84]

Ok. You can STFU now. Because Ok St losing to Iowa State isn't an issue then.

According to you that doesn't matter. All that matters is putting the two best teams in. Ok St being undefeated or not, to you, is immaterial in that regard.

I think Bama is better, but Ok St would get in no doubt if they won.

Was that confusing??

 

[KNUBB]

Bama homers are worse than Me and NAHSTE

 

[FirstTimer]

I think Bama is better, but Ok St would get in no doubt if they won.

Was that confusing??

No. It's just stupid based on all the other bullshit you've spewed previously.

We get it. You're a dumb ass Bama fan.

Roll Tide.

They took yer jerb.

STFU

 

[DSpydr84]

Bama homers are worse than Me and NAHSTE

Welcome to a forum, bro.

 

[DSpydr84]

No. It's just stupid based on all the other bullshit you've spewed previously.

We get it. You're a dumb ass Bama fan.

Roll Tide.

They took yer jerb.

STFU

Or maybe you just haven't understood anything I said?

 

[FirstTimer]

Or maybe you just haven't understood anything I said?

I understood your Opie ass perfectly fine. Hence why I know what you said was stupid.

 

[NAHSTE]

Bottom line: The rankings are/always will be fucked up. Stripping everything away and looking at Team A against Team B, I think the best two teams are LSU and Alabama. And since that is the case, they should compete for the National Championship.

Oh, now I get it. We're just stripping everything away. Got it. Bye bye, home loss to LSU! You don't matter anymore, you've been stripped away! Alabama is arbitrarily the 2nd best team in the country thanks to nothing that their on-field performance tells us. You see, we just stripped the football away and went with whatever the fuck we wanted!

Love when it works like that.

 

[FirstTimer]

Stripping everything away I vote for Notre Dame.

 

[DSpydr84]

Oh, now I get it. We're just stripping everything away. Got it. Bye bye, home loss to LSU! You don't matter anymore, you've been stripped away! Alabama is arbitrarily the 2nd best team in the country thanks to nothing that their on-field performance tells us. You see, we just stripped the football away and went with whatever the fuck we wanted!

Love when it works like that.

This has been college football for 50 years. Why is everyone surprised about an argument now?

 

[NAHSTE]

This has been college football for 50 years. Why is everyone surprised about an argument now?

Um, no it hasn't, and your argument would still suck donkey balls even if it has.

 

[DSpydr84]

Stripping everything away I vote for Notre Dame.

And that's your opinion, sarcasm or not. Whether I like it or not, if you're a voter, that's your right to say Notre Dame should play.

This is the world of college football. You think I want it like this?

 

[FirstTimer]

This is God awful.

 

[DSpydr84]

Um, no it hasn't, and your argument would still suck donkey balls even if it has.

Then let's go with Houston vs LSU like mentioned earlier. Only fair way.

 

[FirstTimer]

Stripping everything away...

Hmm..

Akron!

 

[NAHSTE]

Then let's go with Houston vs LSU like mentioned earlier. Only fair way.

Fine with me. As is playing Oklahoma State. As is playing Alabama because we will butt rape either one.

But Alabama is the least deserving of the three, having not even won its conference.