Enough is enough. Peyton Manning is the greatest QB of all time.

[Maynard]

Yep, different era where the super bowl was the NFC title game and the AFC was just playing to see who would get whooped

Elways teams were garbage, Manning even was below average when he won his, dude has choked to much at this point

Also, not calling someone the GOAT is not a knock, he just doesn't have the big game in him enough it seems to be it, it has been his for taken and he keeps throwing picks

exactly. Manning is a phenominal qb. but he is not the greatest of all time. no way can you call a guy who chokes in the big games the goat. you have to look at the total package when calling someone the greatest. manning does not have the big game wins and the people in this thread are just throwing that fact aside like it doesnt matter.

[JimLeavy59]

Aids for a third time.

[Maynard]

"Enough is enough".
Seriously this Manning GOAT talk is silly now. Don't blame the running game , the protection blah blah blah. If all of that is good enough to score more points than any team in NFL history and have a disgusting 55-10 ratio for Manning it's good enough not to get manhandled and held to a lulz worthy 8 points. Can't give credit to a guy for being some field general for fooling teams and bluffing people at the LOS then brush off his screwing up the opening play where everyone but him seemed to be off at the snap. Being unable to to adjust to the small change in defense until the second half etc etc.

Sorry SBs aren't week 7 match ups. The pressure and nerves get to people or bring out the best in others. Manning isn't that guy to step up his game. Can't be GOAT just to make yourself feel good. Montana's SB record and performances are just light years ahead at this point.

i made this point 2 pages ago, but some people were to fat to understand

[Youk]

dont talk about this nonsense unless you post facts to support it

Someone forgot their own advice.

[Houston]

Reading through this thread you'd think Peyton doesn't already have a ring.

[Maynard]

If your argument against Manning is big games, go for it, but you absolutely can not bring up Elway. Elway was pretty awful in three out of five Super Bowls, and if you want to rip Manning for getting blown out tonight, Elway was blown out in one of the two Super Bowls where he played decent.

if your argument is for manning then you cant ignore the big games.

[Youk]

if your argument is for manning then you cant ignore the big games.

I think you're missing the point....ah fuck it. It's hopeless. This has to be a joke, right?

[JimLeavy59]

if your argument is for manning then you cant ignore the big games.

But you can't throw out his entire body of work as well. Stop living in this ESPN culture bro.

[Liquidrob]

Saying someone isnt the greatest doesn't mean he sucks

Stop being a bunch a goofs

[Maynard]

But you can't throw out his entire body of work as well. Stop living in this ESPN culture bro.

his entire body of work is not enough to make him the goat. you want to give him the title but you only want to base it on his regular seasons and his stats.

his playoff record and failure in the big games must also be taken into account. you guys are just disregarding it like that doesnt matter

he is a great QB, but not the greatest of all time

[Youk]

his entire body of work is not enough to make him the goat. you want to give him the title but you only want to base it on his regular seasons and his stats.

his playoff record and failure in the big games must also be taken into account. you guys are just disregarding it like that doesnt matter

he is a great QB, but not the greatest of all time

But wait

dont talk about this nonsense unless you post facts to support it

[Maynard]

if you need me to post some info to support mannings post season failure then you are a retard and know less than rams about football

[Guest]

Prediction: 15 posts until Maynard challenges Youk to a game of flag football, and then wimps out on it

[JimLeavy59]

if you need me to post some info to support mannings post season failure then you are a retard and know less than rams about football

[Maynard]

you want some cheap thanks now thomas? i guess the no trolling rules have been lifted?