Buzzman
Senior Member
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011)
Cunningly clumsy Capt. Jack Sparrow (Johnny Depp) meets his match when mysterious beauty Angelica (Penélope Cruz) forces the pirate to join her in search of the Fountain of Youth in the fourth installment of the humorous and action-packed "Pirates of the Caribbean" franchise. Sparrow tries to determine whether Angelica is friend or foe while the riotous adventure sets him aboard a vessel belonging to the fearsome pirate Blackbeard (Ian McShane).
If you are like any sane person on this earth, you’ve had enough Pirates of the Caribbean to last you a lifetime. After you saw the first one, you thought they were onto something good, but everything after that just kept getting worse and worse until the third one seemed to kill any good that came away from the first one. Yet here we are with the fourth entry in the franchise that nobody wanted nor asked for.
This time around the film focuses on the fountain of youth and the powers it possesses. Three parties covet to control its powers. The first being the new villain, Blackbeard. A prophecy has been that he will die soon at the hands of Barbosa, so naturally his first place to travel to is the same place Barbosa is headed to. That would be my first choice as well. For no other reason than to introduce a new flame for Jack, Angelica (Cruz) decides to tag along and help save her father’s soul, while dragging Jack along with her. Then you have the Spaniards, who are complete joke and forgotten group. Then you have the British who want it simply because the Spanish want it as well. That’s where Barbosa comes in and begins his journey of other intentions there. The entire thing felt like it was written in one afternoon sitting. The big difference between this installment and the others is at least the others had huge over the top action sets that occasionally made the time pass faster. All you get here is a rather predictable boring story, outside of the surprisingly scary mermaid encounter.
The main reason the film comes off so boring and lazy is old characters feeling stale and the new ones feeling absolutely pointless. Jack Sparrow was always at his best when he was working behind someone rather it be Barbosa, William, or Elizabeth. His humorous behavior and dialogue was never too much. They made the mistake here of focusing just about the entire time on Jack, and this time he felt like last year’s cool toy, but the problem is that something better has come along and he is old news. Then Barbosa is just ridiculous. He has no reason to be here other than that he is a recognizable face. The fact that he’s working with the British seems laughable considering the strict policy they have had on pirates; not to mention Geoffrey Rush looking like he got hit with a make-up covered ugly stick here. Blackbeard is a terrible villain for this kind of movie. Where Barbosa and Davey Jones brought fun into the adventure, Blackbeard is just plain and depressing. McShane acted without emotion the entire time and made you wonder why Angelica wanted to save his soul so much. Cruz as Angelica was so forgettable; I am going to just stop here about her.
Unless you loved the third one, I do not picture many people actually enjoying this. I will say it was better than the third one merely because it was thirty minutes shorter, but it doesn’t offer much that you haven’t already seen before. Do yourself a favor and just pass on by this forgettable entry in a forgettable franchise.
Overall Score: 4/10
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c1e8d/c1e8d37c0f8837d846cad36b81dbbc72459a9e02" alt="2011piratesofthecaribbe.jpg"
Cunningly clumsy Capt. Jack Sparrow (Johnny Depp) meets his match when mysterious beauty Angelica (Penélope Cruz) forces the pirate to join her in search of the Fountain of Youth in the fourth installment of the humorous and action-packed "Pirates of the Caribbean" franchise. Sparrow tries to determine whether Angelica is friend or foe while the riotous adventure sets him aboard a vessel belonging to the fearsome pirate Blackbeard (Ian McShane).
If you are like any sane person on this earth, you’ve had enough Pirates of the Caribbean to last you a lifetime. After you saw the first one, you thought they were onto something good, but everything after that just kept getting worse and worse until the third one seemed to kill any good that came away from the first one. Yet here we are with the fourth entry in the franchise that nobody wanted nor asked for.
This time around the film focuses on the fountain of youth and the powers it possesses. Three parties covet to control its powers. The first being the new villain, Blackbeard. A prophecy has been that he will die soon at the hands of Barbosa, so naturally his first place to travel to is the same place Barbosa is headed to. That would be my first choice as well. For no other reason than to introduce a new flame for Jack, Angelica (Cruz) decides to tag along and help save her father’s soul, while dragging Jack along with her. Then you have the Spaniards, who are complete joke and forgotten group. Then you have the British who want it simply because the Spanish want it as well. That’s where Barbosa comes in and begins his journey of other intentions there. The entire thing felt like it was written in one afternoon sitting. The big difference between this installment and the others is at least the others had huge over the top action sets that occasionally made the time pass faster. All you get here is a rather predictable boring story, outside of the surprisingly scary mermaid encounter.
The main reason the film comes off so boring and lazy is old characters feeling stale and the new ones feeling absolutely pointless. Jack Sparrow was always at his best when he was working behind someone rather it be Barbosa, William, or Elizabeth. His humorous behavior and dialogue was never too much. They made the mistake here of focusing just about the entire time on Jack, and this time he felt like last year’s cool toy, but the problem is that something better has come along and he is old news. Then Barbosa is just ridiculous. He has no reason to be here other than that he is a recognizable face. The fact that he’s working with the British seems laughable considering the strict policy they have had on pirates; not to mention Geoffrey Rush looking like he got hit with a make-up covered ugly stick here. Blackbeard is a terrible villain for this kind of movie. Where Barbosa and Davey Jones brought fun into the adventure, Blackbeard is just plain and depressing. McShane acted without emotion the entire time and made you wonder why Angelica wanted to save his soul so much. Cruz as Angelica was so forgettable; I am going to just stop here about her.
Unless you loved the third one, I do not picture many people actually enjoying this. I will say it was better than the third one merely because it was thirty minutes shorter, but it doesn’t offer much that you haven’t already seen before. Do yourself a favor and just pass on by this forgettable entry in a forgettable franchise.
Overall Score: 4/10