FirstTimer
Freeman Error
I understand this is the internet where we have to take opinions to the extreme, but the truth is probably somewhere in the middle.
I suspect early on that the idea was to bury all of this after the 1998 investigation (hence the "shocking" retirement of Sandusky), but Sandusky was such a brazen, serial offender that everything eventually spiraled out of control.
The serious lack of judgement was allowing Sandusky to keep hanging around, and then showing a complete loss of good judgement when he was still allowed to hang around after the 2001 incident. The longer it went, the deeper the shit they all knew they were in, so, well, they kept it going.
Paterno probably figured early on that it was best for all parties for this thing to just quietly go away. And to be honest, that investigation in 1998 didn't net a single charge, so I don't have a major problem with that. The problem, is instead of just forcing Sandusky out, they should have shunned him from the campus, and that was the major failure here. Everything that happened after fell into "save your own ass" territory, deeper and deeper each passing year, and is obviously inexcusable.
IIRC didn't they determine the Sandusky "retirement" in 1998 pre-date the original 1998 incident? I thought they report found no indication that the 1998 incident had anything to do with Paterno telling Sandusky that the wouldn't be the next coach.