So......

[Nukleopatra]

Rodgers is the first QB in NFL history to post 4000 yard seasons in his first 2 years as a starter. He's poised to become the first to do it in his first 3 seasons as a starter.

Put a playoff victory or a division title behind that, it might actually impress me.

Otherwise, he's just Kyle Orton.

 

[Nukleopatra]

Now he groans when he can't troll anymore. Welcome to VSN.

Depends on your definition of ''trolling.'' I could be groaning to get some dumbass to respond to the groans - but so far, no bites.

....oh wait.

 

[Woy]

Peyton Manning.
Tom Brady.
Philip Rivers.
Big Ben.
Matt Ryan.
Drew Breeees.
Sam Bradford.
Eli Manning.
Mike Vick.
Tony Romo.

Coin toss for the remaining spots - Cutler, Garrard, Aaron Rodgers, Mark sanchez, Joe Flacco.

Thanked cause I don't see Matt Schaub on that list.

 

[Primetime]

Put a playoff victory or a division title behind that, it might actually impress me.

Otherwise, he's just Kyle Orton.

:jonesy:

Let's rag on a guy for having a 121.4 passer rating, 5 touchdowns, and 423 yards, leading his team to 45 points in his first career playoff game. Yea, let's rag on him for the defense giving up 45 points.

You're trying too hard.

 

[Primetime]

Depends on your definition of ''trolling.'' I could be groaning to get some dumbass to respond to the groans - but so far, no bites.

....oh wait.

I bit before you groaned anything. Nice logic once again.

 

[Nukleopatra]

Thanked cause I don't see Matt Schaub on that list.

I'm glad you mentioned that, because the only QB more overrated than Aaron Rodgers, is Matt Schaub. But I'm sure 2011 will be ''The Texans year.''

Whenever I want a few laughs, I log into VSN during the preseason, to see people overrate both Schaub and Rodgers - It gives me something to look forward to, seeing one guy have absolutely no fucking clue as to what he's doing, and the other guy suffer five concussions every year.

Houston vs. Green Bay, 2012 superbowl, for sure.

 

[mgoblue2290]

Rodgers is the first QB in NFL history to post 4000 yard seasons in his first 2 years as a starter. He's poised to become the first to do it in his first 3 seasons as a starter.

Yeah he sucks guys.

BUT HE COULDN'T GET A FIRST DOWN AGAINST THE LIONS IN THE FIRST QUARTER BEEEOOOTTCCHH!!!!!

 

[inthecards21]

you talk like rodgers concussions are all his fault, like sam bradford's two terrible picks today, but in fact it is rodgers O-line that fails him

 

[Primetime]

Rodgers has 2 concussions in 100 sacks the last 3 years. You logic is immaculate.

 

[Nukleopatra]

you talk like rodgers concussions are all his fault, like sam bradford's two terrible picks today, but in fact it is rodgers O-line that fails him

I'm still trying to figure out what your purpose is in this fucking thread. I can understand Prime and Anus, they're GB fans - but you're posting shit that doesn't even make sense. Are you telling me that Aaron Rodgers is comparable to Sam Bradford? And how exactly does that make Aaron Rodgers case any better?

Okay. Aaron Rodgers, at this time, is slightly better than Sam Bradford.

Of course, at this time, if I were a GB fan, I would hope Aaron Rodgers would be a lot better than a rookie QB playing for a 1-15 team. Unfortunately for GB fans, Sam Bradford could possible end the season with more division titles. But yeah, you win, Rodgers is slightly better, right now.

 

[Primetime]

you talk like rodgers concussions are all his fault, like sam bradford's two terrible picks today, but in fact it is rodgers O-line that fails him

Wait what? The offensive line has an influence on the presence of injuries? Who fucking knew...

 

[Nukleopatra]

Big Ben won a superbowl with one of the worst lines in the NFL.

Aaron Rodger's clearly holds onto the ball too long, he's been doing it for years.

 

[inthecards21]

I'm still trying to figure out what your purpose is in this fucking thread. I can understand Prime and Anus, they're GB fans - but you're posting shit that doesn't even make sense. Are you telling me that Aaron Rodgers is comparable to Sam Bradford? And how exactly does that make Aaron Rodgers case any better?

Okay. Aaron Rodgers, at this time, is slightly better than Sam Bradford.

Of course, at this time, if I were a GB fan, I would hope Aaron Rodgers would be a lot better than a rookie QB playing for a 1-15 team. Unfortunately for GB fans, Sam Bradford could possible end the season with more division titles. But yeah, you win, Rodgers is slightly better, right now.

Im trying to make the case that aaron rodgers isnt a "overrated, fragile sack of fucking shit" like you seem to think, also im arguing here because i saw a point i disagreed with and countered it, pretty simple course of events. I dont just argue about my team.

Also, a possible division title in the worst division the NFL has seen in years

 

[inthecards21]

Big Ben won a superbowl with one of the worst lines in the NFL.

Aaron Rodger's clearly holds onto the ball too long, he's been doing it for years.

With one of the greatest defenses in the NFL, also IMO Ben is better than Rodgers, of course i dont want to argue over that because my homer would be showing

 

[Nukleopatra]

Im trying to make the case that aaron rodgers isnt a "overrated, fragile sack of fucking shit" like you seem to think,

Depends on where you have him rated.

If he's higher than 8th, he's overrated.

 

[Primetime]

Big Ben won a superbowl with one of the worst lines in the NFL.

Aaron Rodger's clearly holds onto the ball too long, he's been doing it for years.

And Big Ben's offense lost their starting RB, #1 receiving target, and had his #1 possession receiver out for several games? Seriously Nuk, you can't do any better than this? I thought you were a better troll.

 

[inthecards21]

Manning
Rivers
Brady
Brees
Ben/Rodgers Tie

 

[Colonel Angus]

BUT HE COULDN'T GET A FIRST DOWN AGAINST THE LIONS IN THE FIRST QUARTER BEEEOOOTTCCHH!!!!!

That's because the Lions defense was playing lights out for most of the game. Detroit is not a gimme win anymore - I've been saying this the entire season and not just because they won today.

Another point - Sam Bradford has something Aaron Rodgers does not: a very good running threat. It's a hell of a lot easier for a QB to rack up passing stats when the defense has 8 men in the box. Rodgers has had to carry the offense on his back and for the most part has done a great job. He has yet to miss a start and probably won't. What happened today happens to every quarterback (for the most part) during an NFL season unless they're named Favre (until recently). It is what it is. Concussions don't play into durability when you're head is bouncing off the turf. Rodgers just needs to learn to fucking slide.

 

[Nukleopatra]

With one of the greatest defenses in the NFL, also IMO Ben is better than Rodgers, of course i dont want to argue over that because my homer would be showing

You can homer all you want, because Ben is a better NFL quarterback than Rodgers. He can make a bad situation good, when Aaron Rodgers holds onto the ball far too long at times, because his lack of pocket awareness.

Aaron Rodgers is the kind of QB who needs everything to be working - when guys like Ben, Kurt Warner, can take a bad situation, and make it better.

 

[Primetime]

Depends on where you have him rated.

If he's higher than 8th, he's overrated.

So now it's okay to have him in the top 10, let alone top 8. Hmmmmm...