Who is the most overrated and underrated player?

[Point Blank]

lol @ Chris Houston being overrated. He sucks..

 

[kmanharris]

this is an opinion guys, an opinion

 

[Magnetic Spectrum]

well willie is overatted doesn't play like he use to and he's a little injure prone,c williams is always trying to run people over for one yd gains,and is out performed by dunn and graham.

 

[Maestro]

well willie is overatted doesn't play like he use to and he's a little injure prone,c williams is always trying to run people over for one yd gains,and is out performed by dunn and graham.

He cant try to out perform then,he just came back from a potential career ending injury,i dont expect him to perform that well.By the way Graham was only there last year,and Dunn just came this year,he has been injured its impossible to out perform when your not able to play.And since Parker's second year he has had-1,202-1,494-1,316yrds on the ground.His numbers this years are only down because he only has played in 9 games because of injury.

 

[Maestro]

Barrett Ruud.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ss8h-cX9Ia0&feature=related

I agree with Barrett Ruud being underrated.

 

[Magnetic Spectrum]

c williams before the injury wasn't that great,then he slowly started to decline,

 

[Archer]

then we shouldn't even talk about the nfl then, because i guarentee nobody unless its their job watches every single game.

I try not to comment on games i dont see

 

[Archer]

Not trying to argue here but

I wudnt say Larry Johnson is overated , hes just finished , the chiefs ran him an insane amount a few years ago , i remember when they went 8-8 he broke the carries per season record by a bit , i think his carrer is just done unless he suddenly gets an awesome oline and most broadcasters/media ppl know this it seems . And lt overated?? i mean is this just one season or what , dudes been amazing last 3-5years and hes overated , hes injured (i know just a toe) but most players are told to sitout with his injury cause only rest can heal it but hes out their every week playing , the only thing that makes LT sound overated is the commentators who never shut up about him.

But my list is

Overated : Antonio Croamartie (sure some big plays , but he gives up way too much) , Aaron Rodgers , Braylon Edwards and Lendalle White (bit byist maybe)

Underated : Barret Ruud , Gaines Adams , Pierre Thomas , Deangelo Williams (starting to get credit now) , Clint Session and maybe boldin , just in the fact that i think hes better than Fitzgerald IMO but isint shown as much love it seems

 

[G-men]

overrated: tony romo, terrell owens, roy williams (both), deangelo hall, chad johnson, plaxico burress

underrated: steve smith (giants), kevin boss, santana moss, pierre thomas, barrett ruud, kelvin hayden, brandon flowers,

 

[~Chance~]

Under- Derrick Bugress

Over-Eddie Royal, Tony Homo.

 

[Archer]

overrated: tony romo, terrell owens, roy williams (both), deangelo hall, chad johnson, plaxico burress

underrated: steve smith (giants), kevin boss, santana moss, pierre thomas, barrett ruud, kelvin hayden, brandon flowers,

can you tell hes a giants fan lol?

 

[Wildcard]

overrated: tony romo, terrell owens, roy williams (both), deangelo hall, chad johnson, plaxico burress

underrated: steve smith (giants), kevin boss, santana moss, pierre thomas, barrett ruud, kelvin hayden, brandon flowers,

Under- Derrick Bugress

Over-Eddie Royal, Tony Homo.

How is Tony Romo over rated?

 

[stevsta]

How is Tony Romo over rated?

you know that game over pittsburgh yeah thats why

 

[Wildcard]

you know that game over pittsburgh yeah thats why

1 game.

You must not have watched it.

 

[Primetime]

Tony Romo is not overrated. He is not elite until he win a playoff game, similar to McGrady for the Rockets, but he is still a great quarterback. He missed like a month and is only 4 TD's behind the league leader. Cowboys should be able to make the playoffs this year and if they do, it will be interesting to see how Romo does.

 

[corbin]

I agree, I can't see Romo being overrated. The Cowboys have a few players in my eyes that are overrated but not Tony Romo.

 

[Gonzo]

Not trying to argue here but

I wudnt say Larry Johnson is overated , hes just finished , the chiefs ran him an insane amount a few years ago , i remember when they went 8-8 he broke the carries per season record by a bit , i think his carrer is just done unless he suddenly gets an awesome oline and most broadcasters/media ppl know this it seems . And lt overated?? i mean is this just one season or what , dudes been amazing last 3-5years and hes overated , hes injured (i know just a toe) but most players are told to sitout with his injury cause only rest can heal it but hes out their every week playing , the only thing that makes LT sound overated is the commentators who never shut up about him.

But my list is

Overated : Antonio Croamartie (sure some big plays , but he gives up way too much) , Aaron Rodgers , Braylon Edwards and Lendalle White (bit byist maybe)

Underated : Barret Ruud , Gaines Adams , Pierre Thomas , Deangelo Williams (starting to get credit now) , Clint Session and maybe boldin , just in the fact that i think hes better than Fitzgerald IMO but isint shown as much love it seems

Clint session is one of the more underrated hard-hitting defensive players in the game.

 

[Maestro]

Where is this Rodgers is overrated coming from,seriously its his 1st season and he's 9th overall is passer rtg.He hasa thrown more td's and less int's then the beloved Brett Favre.

 

[Primetime]

He's also 5-9 with no leadership ability.

 

[Primetime]

If you are saying he not overrated strictly on stats, than I agree with you.