Cowboys draft was pure horsehit. With the pick we gave to Detroit in the 3rd round, the Lions used it on Derrick Williams, WR out of Penn State. I remember when that dude was being recruited as the Top Prospect as an Athlete (QB, RB, WR, DB). He was that good coming out of high school ... but made a dumb decision to go to a school that made him the #1 wideout on a running team. Anyways, I was really hoping that the Cowboys would draft him but it looks like instead we wasted it on Robert Brewster. I say Brewster because he has less of a shot at seeing playing time than Jason Williams. If you're going to draft for depth on the offensive line, you don't draft them so early, especially when it was only your second fucking pick in the whole god-forsaken draft. So we draft Brewster, a player that will see almost no playing time this season, instead of a player of Derrick Williams' talent only to take a WR that might be better than Juaquin Iglesias in the 7th round. FWIW, Williams was drafted before Iglesias.
Of our draft choices, I like the odds of 1 of the 3 4th round picks having a better career than anybody else on this list, with the exception of maybe Mickens out of Cincinnati.. My money is Brandon Williams being the better 4th round pick.
OLB Jason Williams, Western Illinois
Who? He's 6'1, 241-lbs. Athletic and fast as hell. Sounds fine and dandy with me ... until I realized that we pretty much wasted our first draft selection on a god damn special teams player.
OT Robert Brewster, Ball State
Good size. Likely to move inside at guard. Perfect, logical choice ... until you consider that Jamon Meredith went in the 5th round to the fucking Packers. Meredith had the best technique out of a lot of the linemen. You need guys that have a fucking clue the first day they get in the NFL. Meredith already had a fucking clue. His technique was pretty sound. Could definatly be stronger, meatier, whatever, but that's why they pay for their trainers. Meredith is more NFL ready than most linemen that were drafted before him, excluding those in the First Round.
QB Stephen McGee, Texas A&M
Good prospect for a career backup. Mike Sherman, apparently his coach, says he's a good prospect for the NFL. I make it a point to point that out because I ready that Mike Sherman should know because he coached Brett Favre at Green Bay. Ummm, last I checked Mike Holmgren put Brett Favre on the fucking map and Favre took it from there. Sherman did not have much to do in molding him. Still, I like him as a developmental pick.
DE Victor Butler, Oregon State
6'2" 248-lb defensive end ... that will definatly be moving to OLB because his size warrents no look at DE in the 3-4 scheme. Once again, he's a special teams player and likely won't see that many snaps as a backup DE. On paper, he's small.
DE Brandon Williams, Texas Tech
6'5" 252-lbs, another OLB prospect. Better size than Butler and there is word that he would have been better served playing his final season at Texas Tech instead of entering the draft.
CB DeAngelo Smith, Cincinnati
Decent size, zone coverage cornerback. Could be moved to safety if we wanted but with the losses of Henry and Jones, he's got better odds as the 4th or 5th corner.
FS Michael Hamlin, Clemson
Great size for a safety. Not particularly fast but hits hard.
K David Buehler, USC Trojans
Ummmmmm, can someone please shoot Jerry Jones for me. I'd really fucking appreciate it. Nick Folk was 91% on his field goals last season and perfect on his PATs. I understand the need for competition ... but why waste a fucking draft pick on a kicker when you could just as fucking easily pick one up in the free agency pool after the fucking draft. When your kicker has already solidified his roster spot during the last two seasons of fantastic play, why would you waste a draft choice on a kicker? Ummm, according to Jerry Jones, it's because he's a physical specimen.
SS Stephen Hodge, TCU
Just more roster fodder as we continue our search for a starting safety that can cover and is not scared to tackle after the NFL Rules Committee names one specifically after you when you couldn't tackle in the first place. Oh, I'll give Roy Williams credit for having a vice grip on the backside neck of the shoulder pads. That takes some serious muscles to be able to grab a hold of that spot, hang on for dear life and drag someone down that is going full speed.
TE John Phillips, Virginia
Need pick. 3rd TE, won't see a lot of snaps. Perfect spot to be drafted. Makes the most logical sense.
CB Mike Mickens, Cincinnati
When was the last time the Cowboys picked two players from the same University that plays the same position? According to reports, he is better than his partner, DeAngelo Smith. Led the nation in interceptions, blazing fast. You can't coach speed ... well, yes you actually can, but the deal here is that he already comes with speed. Could push for the nickel duties. Great value pick.
WR Manuel Johnson, Oklahoma
Heard that he was better at catching the ball than Iglesias and he's got good speed. He definately has a shot at slot receiver, most likely seeing more time at the 4th or 5th spot though.
Let's break it down.
I think the J. Williams pick is solid. Dude's very raw but already shows flashes of being a playmaker. 14 Forced fumbles for his career. Former safety. Dude could be our Joker next to Bradie James for a long time.
Not crazy about Brewster, but let's be honest, when was the last time we drafted a quality offensive lineman? Par for the course.
Really like the McGee pick, even though I would have preferred Bomar. Heard many a scout say McGee was cast in the wrong offense and will be a solid pro with some fine tuning. Might be the guy to run some wildcat stuff, but otherwise won't see the field as long as Kitna's here and Romo stays healthy.
Butler will be a good special teamer if nothing else. This and B.Williams starts to signal the end of Greg Ellis' tenure.
B.Williams led the Big 12 in sacks last year. Same conference as Orakpo. I look forward to this guy being a future in our rush packages. He's gonna contribute. Room to grow.
Smith compares to Scandrick in some ways and if he's anything like Scandrick, we got good value. Might be a contributor at FS.
Hamlin - No comment. I was hoping McBath would fall to us, couldn't believe we passed on Sean Smith.
Buehler? Buehler? (lol) Seriously, I was irate when I first heard this one too, but upon further evaluation, this pick makes sense. Why? Well, as clutch as Nick Folk has been, his kickoffs have been shit. Buehler can boom them, sending 54.4% for touchbacks in his collegiate career. Not only that, but he's not going to be a target to be run over should a returner break one on us. The guy can tackle and as stated, is a physical specimen (outbenched a few top tier linemen at the combine). This could be a boon for our special teams (more on that in a moment).
Hodge is camp fodder.
Phillips is an upgrade to Tony Curtis. Can play H-back as well. Solid pickup for his draft position.
Mickens if healthy could be the steal of the draft. Meniscus is a concern, but our training staff is among the best. This guy makes the 53 for sure.
Manuel Johnson - More special teams fodder. Decent returner, has potential to be something more, but let's cross that bridge when we get there.
All in all, this draft wasn't sexy at all, as we've been accustomed to. But to me, there were three significant weaknesses over the last year with this football team:
Crippling mistakes - This is penalties, miscues, blown assignments, whatever. This falls on the coaching staff. Can't say what's gonna happen this year, but if those guys have any pride, I would think they would place emphasis on fixing this issue. Also, someone has to reign in Romo, and if we move towards a ball control offense like I think we should, that goes a long way toward doing so.
Depth at key positions (QB, LB) - Guys got hurt, we couldn't deal. Brad Johnson blew goats, Bollinger wasn't much better. Kitna is a massive upgrade behind Romo. McGee I think really has a chance to be special. All these new LBs won't pay immediate dividends, but they will be contributers and they have the potential to have long careers.
Special Teams - Contrary to popular belief, this killed us more than just about anything last year. Singlehandedly cost us the Arizona game. Bruce Read was awful. Kickoff and kick coverage were putrid. We consistently lost the battle for field position, except for punting, because IMO Matt McBriar is the best in the league. And then he broke his foot and we were royally fucked on ST.
We now have a kicker who can actually boot the ball past the 10 and potentially get many touchbacks which will go a long way with our defense continuing to improve under Wade (one of the few things he's doing right). Also, every single one of these players is capable of providing a boost on kick coverage and most importantly, they're all hungry. That's exactly the type of guys you want on you coverage teams. Let's face it, talent is not the Dallas Cowboys' problem. We have the biggest OLine in football. We have the best QB in the conference. We have the best TE. We have a guy who may not be the best WR in the league, but has to potential to be up there. We have this three headed monster at RB. And like it or not, we have a very solid D which continues to get better. Our biggest weakness was clearly special teams and with these kids and the firing of Bruce Read (Joe DeCamillis is considered one of the best in the game), that hopefully won't be an issue.
Yeah, the Giants and Eagles had great drafts. Sexy picks. That's fine. The Eagles will always concern me, but I believe that when focused, they can be handled. Our guys can cover Maclin and Jackson. We just have to keep the pressure on McChunky.
I still believe we're better than the Giants and it's been proven that when we bring our A game, they can't touch us.
We'll see how we look in camp.